Once the virgin goddess, now the single lady...
Images of single ladies as strong leaders, rabble-rousers, and members of all-girl posses have been important cultural icons as least as far back as ancient Greek mythology, with tough virgin goddesses Athena and Artemis. With the release of I Am…Sasha Fierce, Beyoncé released her own fierce single lady alter ego to the world.
Behind her iconic independent image, though, Beyoncé is married to star rapper and music business exec Jay-Z. The singer even broke from her own strict policy against PDA when she told Jay-Z she loved him at the Grammys in early 2010, while accepting one of numerous awards for "Single Ladies (Put a Ring On It)."
How about putting a tattoo on it?
"Single Ladies" is not an anthem of independence throughout. The song actually addresses a jealous ex-boyfriend who failed to propose marriage and lost his chance with the singer. Is the ring line literal, or just a metaphor for the stability that the relationship lacked?
These days, there's plenty of evidence pointing to the fact that marriage is not a precursor to commitment. Oprah Winfrey and her partner Stedman Graham are among many famous people who stay in long-term relationships without getting married—see also Brad Pitt and Angelina Jolie, Simone de Beauvoir and Jean-Paul Sartre, and Leondardo da Vinci, who bequeathed the Mona Lisa to his long-term partner Giacommo Caprotti when he died. Not to mention all the non-celebrities who stick together without marrying; a 2005 report said that 8.1% of coupled households consisted of unmarried heterosexual couples, and the report doesn't take into account unmarried gay households.
Social commentary aside, the real Beyoncé has no reason to be bitter about a ring. She didn't go public with her own $5 million wedding ring until five months into her own marriage. It turns out that when they got married on April 4, 2008, Beyoncé and Jay-Z (whose birthdays are September 4 and December 4, respectively) got matching tattoos of the Roman numeral IV on their ring fingers. When People Magazine asked her why she didn't get an engagement ring, Beyoncé responded, "People put too much emphasis on that. It's just material and it's just silly to me." It's probably safe to surmise that even for Beyoncé, "putting a ring on it" is more a figure of speech than a literal requirement.
Jealousy endures, just like in Othello… or Eclipse.
Okay, it might not be exactly like Othello—no racial controversy, no murder theme, and Beyoncé's lyricists are no Shakespeares. And we can probably also agree that Beyoncé is a little more, um, human than the jealous vamps and werewolves in Eclipse. But the reappearance of the theme of jealousy in all these places reminds us that Beyoncé is toying with an emotion that fascinates all kinds of audiences. And she's not just toying—here it sounds like the lyric is about trying to make her ex jealous.
If we were giving out relationship advice, we might say this was a bad choice, or at least kind of immature. But in a song, it works, and even comes off as kind of empowering. The message is clear: I'm so hot I can have any guy I want, and there's nothing you can do about it, so back off. This is the singer's way of showing that she has power over the guy. What do you think? Is this line empowering, or actually sort of embarrassing? Is trying to make someone jealous a sign of moving on, or a sign of hanging on?