Colonial Virginia was many things.
It was
Thomas Jefferson sitting on a hilltop thinking deeply about the natural rights of all humankind, and
Patrick Henry rising to the floor in the House of Burgesses and declaring that he would rather die than sacrifice his liberty.
But colonial Virginia was also 90,000 people kidnapped in Africa and carried to the colony in the death-filled hold of a slave ship.
Colonial Virginia was the great plantations of
Westover and
Gunston Hall—enormous testimonies to genteel living nestled among fields of sweet-smelling tobacco.
But it was also planter William Byrd II forcing a young slave to drink a pint of urine because he wet his bed—and
Robert "King" Carter cutting off the toes of a slave who resisted other forms of discipline.
Virginia was
George Washington painstakingly copying the rules of good behavior into a diary as an adolescent. But it was also cockfights on Saturday and drunken militia marches through the slave quarters on Sundays.
Virginia was genteel and barbaric, all at the same time. Which was the
real Virginia? They both were.