# At a Glance - Error in Left- and Right-Hand Sums

How far off are the left/right hand sums? It's sort of like thinking about how much a four-year-old colors outside of the lines with his spanking new, easy grip Crayola's.

If *f* is monotonic (either strictly increasing or strictly decreasing) on [*a*, *b*], then the area between *f* and the *x*-axis on [*a*,* b*] will be between *LHS*(*n*) and *RHS*(*n*). If *f* is strictly increasing, *LHS*(*n*) will be smaller and *RHS*(*n*) will be bigger. If *f* is strictly decreasing, *RHS*(*n*) will be smaller and *LHS*(*n*) will be bigger.

Either way, the area between *f* and the *x*-axis on [*a*, *b*] is between the area covered by the *LHS* rectangles and the area covered by the *RHS* rectangles.

We can use this to say roughly how far from reality our estimates with *LHS*(*n*) and *RHS*(*n*) are. Assume *f* is monotonic and let *R* be the area between *f* and the *x*-axis on [*a*,* b*]. Since we know the area of *R* is between *LHS*(*n*) and *RHS*(*n*), the area of *R* can't be farther from either *LHS*(*n*) or *RHS*(*n*) than those two are from each other.

### Sample Problem

Suppose *f* is increasing on [*a*, *b*] and we know that *LHS*(*n*) and *RHS*(*n*) are within 2 of each other. Then *LHS*(*n*) must be within 2 of the actual area, since

*LHS*(*n*) < Actual Area < *RHS*(*n*)

and we know* RHS*(*n*) is within 2 of* LHS*(*n*).

As *n* gets bigger,* LHS*(*n*) and *RHS*(*n*) get closer together. If we take *n* big enough, we can get *LHS*(*n*) and *RHS*(*n*) as close as we want. We can get *LHS*(*n*) and *RHS*(*n*) as close as we want to the real area of *R*, so long as we use enough rectangles.

To know how many rectangles we need, first we need a quick way to calculate the difference between *LHS*(*n*) and *RHS*(*n*). Finding each sum and then subtracting is too much work.

To find the difference between *LHS*(*n*) and *RHS*(*n*) on [*a*, *b*], take the difference between *f*(*a*) and *f*(*b*), then multiply by the width of a sub-interval.

Here's why the trick works. First assume *f* is increasing and nonnegative on [*a*, *b*]. Take *RHS*(*n*) and *LHS*(*n*), where

is the width of a sub-interval.

We can look at the difference between *RHS*(*n*) and *LHS*(*n*) as the area that's covered by the little boxes "in between" the *LHS* and *RHS* rectangles. Now imagine scooting those little boxes over to make one big stack. The area of this stack is still the difference between *RHS*(*n*) and *LHS*(*n*).

The bottom of the stack is at *f*(*a*) and the top of the stack is at *f*(*b*). This means the height of the stack is (*f*(*b*) – *f*(*a*)). The width of the stack is Δ*x*, since that's the width of a sub-interval.This means the area covered by the stack of boxes is

height ⋅ width = (*f*(*b*) – *f*(*a*)) ⋅ Δ*x*.

This is the difference between the right-hand and left-hand sums.

If *f* is increasing then the difference between *LHS*(*n*) and* RHS*(*n*) is

(*f* (*b*) – *f* (*a*)) ⋅ Δ*x*

and if *f* is decreasing then the difference between* LHS*(*n*) and *RHS*(*n*) is

(*f* (*a*) – *f* (*b*)) ⋅ Δ*x*.

We can combine these two formulas into one. If *f* is monotonic, then the difference between *LHS*(*n*) and *RHS*(*n*) is

|*f*(*b*) – *f*(*a*)| · Δ*x*.

This number must always be positive. Right now, we don't care if *LHS*(*n*) or *RHS*(*n*) is bigger. We care about how far apart they are.

We said that if we make *n* big enough (that is, use enough rectangles), we can get *LHS*(*n*) and *RHS*(*n*) as close as we want.

The difference between *LHS*(*n*) and *RHS*(*n*) is

|*f*(*b*) – *f*(*a*)|Δ*x*.

Since

we can write the difference between *LHS*(*n*) and *RHS*(*n*) as

This quantity gets smaller as *n* gets bigger, since the values *a*,* b*, *f* (*a*), and *f* (*b*) don't change when we take more rectangles. If we make *n* big enough, then we can get this quantity to be as small as we want.

#### Example 1

Let |

#### Example 2

Let |

#### Exercise 1

Let *f*(*x*) = *x*^{2}. Calculate the following quantities.

- (
*f*(12) –*f*(0))(12)

- (
*f*(12) –*f*(0))(6)

- (
*f*(12) –*f*(0))(4)

- (
*f*(12) –*f*(0))(3)

- (
*f*(12) –*f*(0))(1)

#### Exercise 2

Let *f*(*x*) = *x*^{2} on the interval [0, 12]. How many rectangles must we use to guarantee that the right- and left-hand sums are within 10
of each other?

#### Exercise 3

Let *f*(*x*) = 4*x* + 6 on the interval [2, 8]. How many rectangles must we use to ensure that the left-hand sum is within 0.25 of the exact area between *f* and the *x*-axis on this interval?

#### Exercise 4

Let *f*(*x*) = *x*^{4} on the interval [-2, -1]. For what values of *n* are *LHS*(*n*) and *RHS*(*n*) within 0.5 of each other on this interval?

#### Exercise 5

Let *f* (*x*) = cos(*x*) on the interval How large must *n* be to guarantee that *LHS*(*n*) is within 0.3 of the exact area between *f* and the *x*-axis on this interval?