unigo_skin
© 2014 Shmoop University, Inc. All rights reserved.
 

Themes

Time to get your learn on: Newton's first law of motion says that objects in motion tend to stay in motion until an outside force acts upon them. It's the law of inertia, which is a fancy way of saying that change is hard. We like to think of it as the First Law of Saturday Mornings. Once you go to sleep, only an outside force (gah, Mom!) can make you wake up before noon.

Well, James Joyce chose Dublin for his stories because "that city seemed to me the centre of paralysis" (source). But paralysis isn't just physical—not for the unlucky characters of Dubliners. Pardon us, but we're going to call it an inertia of the soul. Like when you're so tired, or sad, or conflicted that you just… can't… do anything.

Questions About Inertia

  1. We know that what's so difficult about inertia is busting out of it. But how do these folks get so inert in the first place? How do these characters become so emotionally unmoving— is it a gradual process or does it happen all of a sudden?
  2. There's actually a lot of physical movement in Dubliners, particularly walking. Can you be inert and moving at the same time? How so?
  3. Does Joyce evoke sympathy or scorn for all this lounging around? Do we feel sorry for them or blame them?
  4. What needs to change about Dublin to make it less like Newton's first law? What do the characters want to change about it?

Chew on This

Try on an opinion or two, start a debate, or play the devil’s advocate.

Dead people have a lot more in common with the living in Dubliners than in a lot of books.

If inertia itself makes life miserable, the characters in Dubliners are particularly bad at coping with all of its consequences.

Advertisement
ADVERTISEMENT
Advertisement
back to top