The House of the Scorpion
by Nancy Farmer
The House of the Scorpion Theme of Identity
No one likes it when someone copies them, or wears the same outfit, or has the same shoes. We all want to have our own identity, our own sense of self, right? Okay, so imagine, then, that you are an exact genetic copy of someone else. How in the world are you supposed to be original, when you are literally identical to someone else, right down to your very genes? It's a problem that Matt deals with all throughout The House of the Scorpion, and his identity issues are further complicated by the fact that he's cloned from a Very Bad Man. That's right, Matt's the exact genetic copy of El Patrón, a ruthless dictator and drug lord. As he grows into manhood, Matt has to fight not to follow in El Patrón's footsteps. He struggles to be his own person and make his own decisions. And he's not the only one. Everyone in Opium is under El Patrón's control, and it's hard to be yourself when you have a man like that watching over you. In the end, Matt discovers that he can create his own identity by making choices – decisions that are his and his alone.
Questions About Identity
- How does Matt see himself after he discovers that he is a clone? Do you think at any point that he really believes he might be less-than-human, as others seem to think he is?
- Matt may be El Patrón's clone, but they don't share identical personalities. In what ways are they similar? Different?
- Who do you think plays a bigger role in shaping Matt's identity – Celia or Tam Lin? What roles do they play, exactly? And what do those roles tell you about their identities?
- What character did you identify with most in the book and why?
Chew on This
For Matt, creating an identity that has nothing to do with El Patrón is a very important task.
Matt becomes a nice version of El Patrón at the end of the novel, which is how Matt remains his own person while acknowledging his connection to the former dictator.