The Legend of Sleepy Hollow
Why He's the Protagonist
No one can deny that Ichabod is the main character of "Sleepy Hollow." We meet him first, we follow him around, we know his thoughts, and the story ends when he flees the scene. Whether we like it or not, Ichabod is our main squeeze.
Why We Still Don't Love Him
Just because Ichabod is our protagonist, we don't have to like him. After all, what is there to like? He's mean, greedy, and gluttonous (amongst a whole slew of other nasty adjectives). Actually, we don't even have a reason to justify why he's such a jerk—maybe if Baltus was a stingy old Scrooge and Ichabod was starving… but no such luck. Normally we like our protagonist (although that's not always the case), but even though Ichabod is fun to laugh at (not with), we're not his biggest fans.
Check out Ichabod's "Character Analysis" for more on the whole anti-hero thing he has going on.