Boo! Gotcha! Okay sure, the supernatural can be scary, but isn't there more to it? Are there different types? Can it be funny? Is it real or is it total fluff? And most importantly, was it Brom or the Headless Horseman? We know that's a lot of questions, but "The Legend of Sleepy Hollow" seems like an investigative report about all things supernatural. We end up with more questions than answers, but one thing's for sure in our sleepy little town: whatever it is, the supernatural is going to come for you. So put up your dukes.
It doesn't matter if the supernatural is real in "Sleepy Hollow"; it still has power over people, and that's all that counts.
This isn't a story about the supernatural. After all, the whole thing is totally made up.