by Elizabeth Bishop
Sestina Theme of Isolation
Maybe at first it looks like the grandmother and the child are getting along while they're making jokes from the almanac, but we quickly see they're a million miles away from one another. They're the only ones home, and maybe the only two who even live in the house. The grandmother has some secret sadness that she keeps from the child, and the child, probably sensing this sadness and distance from her grandmother, turns to her imaginative drawing to escape the loneliness. Sure, the two seem to get along just fine, but we can't help but feel that they're too far apart from one another to really be a happy family.
Questions About Isolation
- Where in the poem do you first notice the grandmother and child seem distant from one another? What line best describes that distance?
- Do you think the age gap between the two of them contributes to their feelings of isolation? Or is the gap between them because they're so isolated?
- If they are with each other, why are they lonely? What could be going on to make either of them feel lonely? Do any lines in the poem give you a hint?
- Does the weather enhance the feeling of distance and loneliness? How so?
Chew on This
They're not lonely! They have each other. Sheesh.
The grandmother's sadness has nothing to do with loneliness. She's bummed about something else entirely.