* Site-Outage Notice: Our engineering elves will be tweaking the Shmoop site from Monday, December 22 10:00 PM PST to Tuesday, December 23 5:00 AM PST. The site will be unavailable during this time.
Dismiss
© 2014 Shmoop University, Inc. All rights reserved.
A Tale of Two Cities

A Tale of Two Cities

by Charles Dickens

A Tale of Two Cities Volume II, Chapter Nineteen – An Opinion Summary

  • It’s the tenth day after Lucie’s wedding.
  • Mr. Lorry enters the doctor’s bedroom and finds the doctor sitting by his window, reading.
  • He’s a bit pale, sure, but otherwise he seems to be completely back to normal.
  • The change is so drastic, in fact, that Mr. Lorry begins to doubt his own eyes.
  • When Miss Pross arrives, she’s equally astonished.
  • Doctor Manette seems to have healed himself completely overnight.
  • Because the doctor doesn’t make any reference to his scary relapse, Miss Pross and Mr. Lorry decide not to mention it immediately, either.
  • They all head down to breakfast.
  • While they’re sitting down, Mr. Lorry tells Dr. Manette that he needs an expert’s opinion in a hypothetical case.
  • We all know how much Mr. Lorry loves "hypothetical" cases.
  • Asking the doctor how good friends should deal with the case of a man who relapsed for nine days, Mr. Lorry tries to gauge how much the doctor actually remembers of his relapse.
  • As it turns out, the doctor doesn’t remember anything.
  • He quickly catches on to Mr. Lorry’s ruse; finally, he asks if the daughter of this hypothetical man has been told of his illness.
  • When Mr. Lorry says that the daughter hasn’t been told of her father’s condition, Dr. Manette breathes a huge sigh of relief.
  • Actually, he says, the man probably has been expecting a relapse of this sort for some time.
  • Puzzled, Mr. Lorry asks why.
  • Dr. Manette pauses for a bit before replying.
  • He finally says that the man had probably been anticipating some information from someone he knew well.
  • Actually, anticipating is too nice a word. He’d been dreading the information.
  • When it finally came, his mind crumbled entirely.
  • Surprised, Mr. Lorry asks what the information was.
  • The doctor, of course, can’t say. After all, it’s a hypothetical case.
  • He does reassure Mr. Lorry that another relapse seems highly unlikely.
  • After all, there are no more big shocks in store. Thank goodness.
  • Now comes the tricky part: Mr. Lorry and Miss Pross have come up with a plan.
  • They’re pretty sure that the doctor won’t like it at all.
  • Nevertheless, they decide to give it a go.
  • Mr. Lorry gently tells the doctor that the case they’d been discussing also involved some tools: the man who relapsed began working again at shoemaking.
  • The doctor seems more disturbed than before.
  • Mr. Lorry asks if it wouldn’t be best for friends of the man to take the shoe-making bench away.
  • After all, couldn’t the very presence of the bench in the man’s room help to incite another relapse?
  • Pained by this thought, the doctor explains that the bench was once the only thing which kept him sane.
  • He worked with his hands (making shoes) so that he wouldn’t go crazy while he was in prison.
  • In some ways, then, the bench symbolizes his strength, not his weakness.
  • Mr. Lorry understands this, but he still presses the doctor to get rid of the bench.
  • Finally, the doctor agrees that if the bench could be taken away while the man was out of the house, it might be OK.
  • Accordingly, a few days later the doctor heads out to the country to meet up with Darnay and Lucie.
  • As soon as he leaves, Miss Pross and Mr. Lorry dismantle his workbench and bury the tools in the yard.

People who Shmooped this also Shmooped...

Advertisement
Noodle's College Search
Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement