Thirteen Reasons Why
by Jay Asher
It Wasn't Me
What makes a character stand out? Especially in a book where most of the characters are just names on a list, this is an important question to ask.
Well, Marcus, number six on Hannah's list, is the only listed person that Clay meets while he's listening to the tapes. Before we even get to Marcus's tape, Clay finds him outside Tyler's window passing out rocks for people to throw. Marcus is eager to punish Tyler for peeping, but he brushes off Hannah's accusations about himself. He tells Clay, "It's ridiculous […]. I don't belong on those tapes. Hannah just wanted an excuse to kill herself" (7.184).
Marcus' reaction tells us something about him, but also about the nature of Hannah's list. Marcus definitely doesn't think he did anything wrong, yet he's super quick to assume that what Hannah says about Tyler is true – and blameworthy. Don't you think that everyone on that list might feel the same way?
Turn for the Worse
As we discuss in "Symbols, Imagery, and Allegory," Marcus represents a turning point for Hannah. After he tries to force her to let him touch her sexually in a booth at Rosie's Diner, Hannah begins to seriously consider suicide. Marcus asks her out, then humiliates and assaults her in a public place.
Unfortunately, Hannah picks the wrong guy to work out her trust issues with. Marcus, and his perversion of what should have been a fun Valentine's Day game, helps convince Hannah that every choice she makes in matters of the heart is the wrong one. In addition to losing trust in others, Hannah is starting to lose trust in herself and her ability to make good decisions.