© 2016 Shmoop University, Inc. All rights reserved.



by Scott Westerfeld

Sol and Ellie

Character Analysis

Sol and Ellie are like cool parents—the kind of parents who are fun when they're someone else's parents and maybe not so great when they're yours. And they're the perfect foils for Maddy and Az, David's parents:

  1. Maddy and Az are smart and committed to the rebellion; Sol and Ellie are brain damaged and committed to the status quo. 
  2. Maddy and Az are called "mom" and "dad" by David; Sol and Ellie are called "Sol" and "Ellie" by Tally. (So David's parents are treated more like parents in that way.) 
  3. Maddy and Az give important info and useful advice to Tally and David; Sol and Ellie give really mediocre advice to Tally.

In fact, this last part is the most important thing that Sol and Ellie do. When Tally is caught between her promise to Shay and her desire to be pretty, her parents tell her that she should help the secret police. (Note: It is almost never the correct option to help the secret police. If they're secret, it's probably because they're doing bad things.)

It's not so important that Sol and Ellie give bad advice—all parents give bad advice. What's important is that this is the first time that Tally recognizes that her parents aren't so smart: "For the first time in her life, Tally found herself listening to a middle pretty without being completely reassured, a realization that made her dizzy. And she couldn't shake the thought that Sol knew nothing about the outside world Shay had fled to" (14.49).

So Sol and Ellie help Tally change her mind by being clueless parents. Whew. Time for clueless parents everywhere to breathe a sigh of relief—they're still doing their job. Sort of.

People who Shmooped this also Shmooped...