ShmoopTube

Where Monty Python meets your 10th grade teacher.

Search Thousands of Shmoop Videos

The Sun Also Rises 32295 Views


Share It!


Description:

This video discusses the important ladies of The Sun Also Rises…make that the one important lady. Brett is the only major female character in the novel, and she’s pretty complex. She’s in a lot of pain, but she also sort of treats men like toys. Is she a sympathetic character? Is she not? It’s up to you to decide—after watching this video.

Language:
English Language

Transcript

00:04

The Sun Also Rises, a la Shmoop. Lady Brett Ashley… is quite the charmer.

00:13

She is also the only female of any significance in The Sun Also Rises. What a sausage fest.

00:21

But we wonder… is Brett a sympathetic character? Let’s back up a tad and get a little background.

00:32

Picture post-World War One Europe. Lots of people are dead.

00:39

This doesn't stop protagonist Jake Barnes and his compadres from gadding about Paris

00:43

and Spain…

00:44

…drinking wine and fishing and watching bullfights, which sounds like a pretty cushy

00:51

life to us.

00:53

The only downside for Jake is that a war wound has rendered him impotent. Ouch. [2]Oh, and

01:00

he's in love with Brett.

01:02

Brett is...Well, she's something.

01:06

She's hot, sexy, smart, divorced, and enjoys spending quality time with the fellas. If

01:15

you know what we mean.

01:17

It's pretty obvious why Jake would have a thing for her.

01:23

Of course, every other male character in the book is in love with Brett, too, and that's

01:27

the problem:

01:28

…her only purpose in life seems to be to create conflict among men.

01:37

We know from the get-go how Jake feels about Brett, and that he's felt this way for years.

01:43

Brett, however, is engaged to a guy named Mike. That's two guys.

01:51

Then there's Jake's friend Robert Cohn, who's recently had an affair with Brett. That's

01:57

three guys.

01:58

Then Brett falls for a young Spanish matador named Romero. That's four guys.

02:05

Four guys. Where does she find the time?

02:13

All that testosterone gets unleashed in bickering, insults, and fisticuffs during the bullfights

02:18

at Pamplona. Way to stir up trouble there, Brett.

02:24

Yet there are reasons to feel sympathy for the lady.

02:27

Here she is, stirring up trouble across two countries, acting as if she has everything

02:31

under control…

02:32

…when in truth, she's been just as damaged by the war as Jake. She is vulnerable, even

02:42

if she doesn't want to show it.

02:44

Hemingway also makes it obvious that Brett is capable of great emotional depth.

02:53

She is so in love with the bullfighter Romero that she ditches her fiance to run off with

02:58

the young Spaniard.

03:00

Not that the relationship works out or anything, but still, E for effort.

03:12

Brett can be a difficult character to like.

03:16

Sure, she's beautiful and intelligent, but she can't help falling into bed with every

03:22

guy she sees, stirring up anger and jealousy.

03:27

She pretends to be debonair about her actions but, in truth, she's as damaged by the upheaval

03:34

of World War One as any of her male friends and conquests.

03:41

She clearly wants to be loved, and is capable of love, but seems unable to reconcile the

03:52

two.

03:53

So, what do you think?

03:57

Is Brett unsympathetic?

03:59

Or does her love for Romero earn her some leeway?

04:03

Shmoop amongst yourselves.

04:05

[1]This intro seems a little misleading. [2]This is a little confusing since the question

04:11

is about Brett and then we jump into a totally different character.

04:12

[3]I think the issue is more that she takes pleasure in it.

04:12

[4]Awkward.

Up Next

Utopias Becoming Dystopias
29763 Views

This video defines utopias and dystopias, and investigates how a utopia might become a dystopia. Can a seemingly perfect world actually be a dystop...

Related Videos

Shakespeare on Love
17376 Views

We may all be fools when it comes to love, but thankfully none of us will accidentally switch places with our twin brother and fall in love with ou...

The Importance of Being Earnest Summary
123036 Views

They say that honesty is the best policy, but Jack lies about his identity and still gets the girl. Does that mean we should all lie to get what we...

The Giver Summary
105891 Views

Ever wish you could remember everything that you ever studied? How about everything that everyone has ever studied? Yeah, pretty sure our brains ju...

Invisible Man (Ellison)
1818 Views

Ralph Ellison's Invisible Man is an American classic. Hope you're not expecting any exciting shower scenes though. It's not that kind of book.