We Used to Wait Images

The revolving door of musicians has always included Win Butler (front center) and Régine Chassagne (far left).

Here the couple puts on a real Sweeney-Todd-esque show of their own strangeness.

This older photo shows a different line-up, but the same basic idea: all indie-goofy-cool, all the time.

Yep, they made the cover of TIME—TIME Canada, that is.

Well, okay, their poses are not really that natural. Anyhow, here is the band in 2010.

In case it rains in the suburbs.

The album was actually released with 8 different covers; this just seems to be the most common one on the internet.