All-Pay Auction

  

Most bidders lose an auction. In an all-pay auction, most bidders really lose.

In a standard auction, people submit bids for some prize, but only the highest bidder actually pays. Meanwhile, the rules of an all-pay auction force everyone to pay, whether they win or not.

The all-pay auction largely exists as a theoretical concept, popular in game theory and in other related economic debates. Conceptually, an all-pay auction should increase the amount the seller gets for the prize, while in theory (you'll notice we're using the word "theory" a lot here) efficient strategy on the buyer's part could lower their costs as well.

After all, traditional lotteries could be described as one-price all-pay auctions where you can choose to bid $1 for a $300 million prize (in that case, you can also vary your bid by buying additional tickets, which do - ever so incrementally - improve your chances to win). But of course, most lottery players lose money over time.

All-pay auctions are also used as metaphors for other aspects of life, such as biological functions. Two rams battling over the affections of a female sheep are engaged in an all-pay auction, since each pays with a headache (or worse) no matter which one wins. In theory, anyway.

Related or Semi-related Video

Finance: What is a Specialist?6 Views

00:00

Finance allah shmoop what is a specialist I wouldn't have

00:06

a movie stallone wait different kind of specialist in finance

00:12

land a specialist is the gala guy trading in a

00:15

given stock that is there a member of a stock

00:18

exchange and they might carry inventory of satan Ten million

00:21

shares of microsoft trading currently at around forty bucks a

00:24

share their offering msft for sale at forty point Oh

00:28

five and they're our buyer of msft this moment at

00:32

thirty nine ninety one and see there's a fourteen cents

00:35

a share spread their meaning that they make fourteen cents

00:39

every time they transact So let's say that specialist sells

00:44

a million shares of microsoft today earning a fourteen cents

00:49

spread per share while fourteen cents times a million one

00:52

hundred forty grand and clown Nice payday for one day's

00:56

work so that's a pretty widespread in the scheme of

00:58

things because often brokers have to tack on their own

01:01

commission of a few cents on either side and the

01:04

specialist might in fact be dealing from their inventory to

01:08

brokers on both sides of a transaction in which case

01:11

they're spread I even spread to the actual specialist might

01:15

Be just a few cents times those million shares like

01:18

four cents times a million gets to forty grand Something

01:21

like that It's still a really good living but if

01:23

it's so good then why don't millions of people fight

01:26

for that job Like how hard is it tio Just

01:29

nod your head and right down buy or sell and

01:32

then a number you think everyone who flips burgers at

01:35

mcdonald's and is afraid of robots taking their jobs would

01:38

be killing for this gig Well in order to be

01:40

a spy specialist not only do you need you know

01:43

special education and a few siri's license exams but you

01:48

also need capital with which to buy inventory risky inventory

01:53

which you'll hold as if they are casino chips and

01:56

you are more or less the house So when the

01:59

microsoft shares example just to be a specialist in that

02:02

one stock well you have to raise something like one

02:04

hundred million dollars because you'll have to go into the

02:07

market to start and simply by two or three and

02:11

call two and a half million shares at around forty

02:13

bucks each for a total cost of a condo or

02:16

a silicon valley unit that's What a units called out

02:19

here and yes that's an investment and the stock could

02:22

go up but it could go down as well leaving

02:24

you holding a big fat smoldering bag of dog craft

02:28

dot com and also going whoever your investors or creditors

02:32

workout hundred million dollars Like if microsoft has kind of

02:36

evaporated you know what could happen More risks will hunt

02:39

your sleep in that the stock and suddenly gap down

02:42

three dollars on a bad quarter at which point your

02:45

spreads must widen to accommodate expected further volatility in the

02:49

stock And you then compete with other specialists who also

02:53

make a market in microsoft Well at any given time

02:56

they may want to get out of trading in it

02:58

and undercut you Buy a penny or two a share

03:00

leaving you as the sole big owner of what will

03:04

feel like a stock version of the titanic Well the

03:07

math gets complex is the market gets volatile specialists use

03:10

hedges and human beings end up competing against a i'd

03:14

driven black box computers But the reason you exist as

03:18

a specialist or rather the key job or responsibility of

03:22

the specialist is to provide liquidity That is you have

03:26

to buy and sell shares to accommodate the market that's

03:30

your job and in volatile markets It means that they

03:33

might run out of inventory or be squeezed and have

03:36

to buy shares at much higher or sell shares at

03:39

much lower prices than their cost But that's the risk

03:43

you take when you become a specialist they must execute

03:46

on these trades and if they don't they lose their

03:48

c This is specialist on the exchange altogether and are

03:52

more or less fully out of work And you know

03:54

i don't know working for uber lift or something next

03:57

Yeah and at that point well they might be willing 00:03:58.973 --> [endTime] Tio take just about anything for a ride

Up Next

Finance: What is an Auction Market?
13 Views

What is an Auction Market? Auction markets are the common stock exchanges. They allow buyers and sellers to enter bids and offers; trades occur whe...

Finance: What is a market maker?
3 Views

What is a market maker? A market maker is an institutional member of an exchange that displays public willingness to trade by listing bids and offe...

Finance: When Can the Data Do You Wrong?
20 Views

When Can the Data Do You Wrong? Often, actually. Things are not always what they seem, at first. It can take careful analysis of data to arrive at...

Finance: What is a Dutch Auction?
3 Views

What is a Dutch Auction? A Dutch Auction is either one where closed quantity and price bids are entered and the price is set at the highest price t...

Find other enlightening terms in Shmoop Finance Genius Bar(f)