Roth IRA Conversion

Categories: Retirement, Wealth, Tax

See: Roth IRA.

A popular thing to do, especially among those moving from high-tax Blue States to low-tax Red States. They'll simply convert their normal IRA into a Roth IRA by paying the gains taxes on that old traditional IRA (ordinary income tax rates when they close it out), and then roll that net saved dollar into a Roth IRA, so that they can just appreciate taxlessly into the future.

Do the math. It may make a ton of sense.

Related or Semi-related Video

Finance: What are IRA distributions, and...1 Views

00:00

Finance allah shmoop what are ira distributions and well how

00:06

do they work Well the big idea here iras or

00:10

individual retirement accounts are not tax free Yeah you do

00:15

pay tax but only when you withdraw the money out

00:19

of the ira Ok so backing up b b pete

00:23

you make eighty grand a year is a union told

00:26

booth worker in california taking five dollar bills from drivers

00:29

and putting them in the little slot thing here Brutal

00:32

rigorous highly stressful job Yes you have a pension that

00:35

the government you work for contributes taxpayer dollars to pay

00:39

for You also have an ira and you contribute five

00:42

grand a year to that ira Well that five grand

00:44

comes out of the eighty grand you'd normally be fully

00:47

taxed on But instead of the eighty grand that the

00:49

irs would normally worry about well as faras they're concerned

00:53

this year you didn't make eighty grand You made seventy

00:56

five grand Why Because you contributed voluntarily five grand to

01:01

your ira and it'll sit in that separate special account

01:04

likely invested in the stock market so that it compounds

01:07

away doubling about every six seven eight nine years until

01:11

you retire with five grand contributions year after year after

01:14

year you'll have a full million bucks in there By

01:16

the time you retire at sixty five and maybe a

01:19

little more maybe it'll left and you'll have the option

01:21

to start withdrawing from the ira at that point Or

01:24

you can wait to start withdrawing the money until you've

01:27

hit the maximum age of seventy and a half at

01:29

which point the law makes you start to withdraw the

01:32

money And there's a whole schedule on when you can

01:34

withdraw it how you can withdraw and all that Anyway

01:37

That withdrawal process is kind of a big deal because

01:40

small tweaks in it make a huge difference Like if

01:42

you had saved money beyond the ira i e Your

01:45

personal savings accounts and could live on that another five

01:49

and a half years Well then if the market followed

01:51

historical patterns instead of beginning your ira withdrawals from a

01:54

base of a million dollars in there While you have

01:57

compounded that million bucks another five and a half years

01:59

worth it so that it was then worth maybe a

02:02

million six or a million seven by the the time

02:04

you were seventeen and a half That's an extra six

02:06

or seven hundred grand there that would happen just for

02:08

you being ableto wait to start withdrawing Well why is

02:12

there a must in there like the government needs to

02:14

tax you somehow right So that's why you must start

02:17

withdrawing it at some point And remember that money went

02:20

into the ira and sat there compounding tax free for

02:23

decades But now when you take it out you'll pay

02:25

ordinary income rates on it So why not the cheaper

02:29

long term gain rates Well why Because it was income

02:32

active income you earned and quote should have been unquote

02:36

taxed as ordinary income when you earned it But you

02:39

weren't so well now it's time for the tax man

02:42

teo You know coming the logic behind the creation of

02:45

the ira was that investors in it would be paying

02:47

a lower tax rates when they were old I e

02:49

making less money as geezers than they did when they

02:52

were in the peaks of their careers So under the

02:55

progressive tax system whose rates look something like this instead

03:00

of paying a marginal rate of say forty three percent

03:03

on that five grand that was saved as a geezer

03:05

taking out relatively small amounts toe live on Well you're

03:08

paying more like thirty percent or less on that marginal

03:11

dollar So how much do you take out of the

03:13

ira Alright well there's that schedule thing again And the

03:16

focus is the minimums you must withdraw What you khun

03:19

distribute to yourself more than the minimums But then you

03:22

have to take out a set percentage each year So

03:25

here's how that works Look at the table here Right

03:27

here They ira required minimum distribution worksheet in eight seventy

03:31

You're going to divide us Say at a million bucks

03:33

in there you're gonna divide that by twenty seven point

03:36

four That's the amount you have to distribute this year

03:38

Let's say the market went up Whatever One twenty seventh

03:41

is more than that even And well then all the

03:44

sudden of a million two or a million three Well

03:47

by aged call it eighty You have to distribute whatever

03:50

that amount is divided by eighteen point seven You get

03:53

all the way to one hundred Well you have to

03:55

basically divided by six and that's the amount you have

03:59

to distribute So let's say you had a i'll say

04:01

had six hundred thousand dollars in there at eight hundred

04:03

you're going divided by six point three means that six

04:06

hundred thousand You have to distribute one hundred grand back

04:08

to yourself leaving you five hundred grand Yeah that's kind

04:11

of how the system works in more or less Anyway

04:13

that twenty seven numbers the denominator in the total assets

04:17

in the ira get divided by it And that's the

04:19

number The ira beneficiary which would be you if it's

04:21

your ira must take out of the ira fund in

04:24

this year and notjust how much age matters here In

04:27

fact it's kind of everything in this calculation So let's

04:31

look at age seventy seven for example the divisor here

04:33

is twenty one point two That means that whatever the

04:35

total assets worrying the ira as of the end of

04:37

the year that amounts divided by twenty one point two

04:40

And it's that amount that must be taken out of

04:42

the ira and quote distributed to you unquote usually in

04:45

the form of your writing A check out of the

04:47

ira to yourself that's housed in your normal brokerage account

04:51

So let's say that at seventy seven you had a

04:53

million bucks from your hard earned scrimping and saving You

04:56

take a million dollars in the numerator and divided by

04:58

twenty one point two to get forty seven thousand one

05:00

hundred seventy dollars It's that amount that you'd have to

05:03

take out of the ira and be taxed on at

05:05

ordinary income rates and well hopefully live to fight another

05:08

day Notice that the divisor increased dramatically as you get

05:11

older here like we said And when the iris starts

05:14

at age seventy divide by twenty seven point four We

05:16

only have to distribute a small amount of doughty yourself

05:19

a few percent and be taxed on it But by

05:21

eight hundred here Yeah you're doing the six point three

05:24

dance Meaning that the government doesn't think you're gonna live

05:26

much longer Well why do they do that Yeah well

05:29

here's the guy thing is knocking really loud by age

05:31

one hundred Very few people live past that age And

05:34

those who d'oh well usually have trouble hearing the doorbell

Find other enlightening terms in Shmoop Finance Genius Bar(f)