Transaction Risk

  

Categories: Insurance

Whatever.com has extra cash. It can pay a dividend. It can buy back its own stock. It can buy a competitor.

Example:

Cendant Corporation. Largest fraud case in modern history in corporate America. The company, which owns rental cars and office space and insurance things and travel things, had a nice "subscription-like" business. It wanted more growth. So it bought CUC (Comp-u-card), one of the early AOL partners who used Groupon-like discounting to market to subscription members all around the world. The transaction was done as an MOE, or Merger of Equals, as the market valuations of both companies was about the same at the time.

The problem? CUC was only actually "worth" about 1/5th of the valuation it had convinced Wall Street to accord it, because it had taken massive merger reserves while it had built its own business over time. That is, it grew by acquiring tons of small companies, overstating the banking and "restructuring costs" (i.e., firing people). That number kept growing and growing on the balance sheet, and investors kinda just ignored it.

Eventually, when the real audit was done, the chickens came home to roost (and poop all over the place), and it came clear that the company was only about 1/3 as profitable as it said it was. So the stock prices of the combined companies went from somewhere in the mid $40s to middle-single-digit-midget status.

And yes, there was massive transaction risk there. For way less money, Cendant (which had no fraud) could have bought back half of its own stock and been just fine as a company...but they took the risk and got bitten. Bad.

Related or Semi-related Video

Finance: What is risk premium?0 Views

00:00

Finance Allah shmoop What is risk premium No it's not

00:07

This movie in three D risk premium comes from the

00:11

notion that when you invest in pretty much anything other

00:13

than US government debt there is more risk in that

00:16

other investment like even by the bonds of Disney or

00:18

Coke or GOOG or some other behemoth company of those

00:22

bonds carry more risk than US government paper And if

00:25

you bought the stocks I even equities not the bonds

00:28

of one of those beam off cos Well there's way

00:30

more risk Well historically stocks have swung up and down

00:33

violently in short periods over time but over long periods

00:37

of time they've gone up Ah lot Well regardless where

00:40

there is more perceived risk investors will demand more potential

00:44

reward Yeah the key idea here every investment carries more

00:48

risk than US government paper So on top of whatever

00:50

U S Government bonds air yielding investors tag on top

00:54

of them a premium investment return that they require to

00:57

be interested in investing So if say a five year

01:00

U S Government bond is yielding three percent and you're

01:03

looking at investing in bonds backed by a controversial low

01:06

warlord Somalian company Well there's at least some tangible risk

01:11

of bankruptcy there right Well then those bonds will carry

01:13

meaningful E a higher yield than the US government five

01:17

year paper If the risk that the company doesn't pay

01:19

back its bond is modest well then maybe that premiums

01:22

only one percent on top and those five year bonds

01:25

yield in a four percent If the risk is big

01:27

they might have to yield eight or ten or fourteen

01:30

percent or more But those were extremely high rates at

01:33

least these days The market's telling you that the company

01:36

and backing the money already has one foot in the

01:38

grave So now let's go to a completely different way

01:40

of thinking about this extra risk your local diner Think

01:43

of our risk free five year U S Government bonds

01:46

of yielding three percent and being priced like a dinner

01:49

salad which is the cheapest item on the menu right

01:51

here So everything else will cost more than that salad

01:55

crew tones included So then when you're ordering if you

01:59

wanted a burger it's total gross Cost is seven bucks

02:02

But you could also describe that cost to the angry

02:05

waitress or friendly robot as dinner salad plus four bucks

02:09

The premium tacked onto the salad price is four dollars

02:12

for the burger Well risk is priced and described the

02:15

same way there has to be added investment return to

02:18

reflect the added risk to the investor on any given

02:20

deal Be careful though There's inherent risk even if all

02:23

you do is order to the salad Especially if there's

02:26

been a romaine lettuce E Coli warning recently issued by

02:29

the CDC And you do not want to go there 00:02:32.288 --> [endTime] My God

Up Next

Finance: What is Counterparty Risk?
9 Views

What is Counterparty Risk? Counterparty risk is the risk to either party within a transaction that the other will not or be unable to abide by the...

Finance: What is Event Risk?
6 Views

What is Event Risk? Event risk just means that some random event has taken place that has affected a company’s ability to conduct business and co...

Finance: What are Systematic and Unsystematic Risk?
14 Views

What are systematic and unsystematic risk? Take a risk on this video and hit play.

Find other enlightening terms in Shmoop Finance Genius Bar(f)