Universal Health Care Coverage

Ooooh...juicy political discussion. "Universal" is a bit of an overstatement, as the policy, as described in the press, really just covers Americans. In some states, illegal citizens as well.

The notion: "everyone gets access to health care." Meaning: taxpayers pay for everyone's health care. And those who bear the lion's share of the taxes will bear the lion's share of the burden of this policy.

In most states, something like half the taxes are paid by the top 2-4% of earners. Want them to move out of the state? Tax 'em higher. (See: Obamacare.) Oh, and other perverse things happen: the self-regulatory elements of health care get tweaked; the incentives to keep healthy, to not eat that third donut, to not smoke...they're all gone. Or, at least...reduced. The government will cover any health issues that come down the pipe, courtesy of the high-tax-payer.

That's how it works, more or less. People get sick though. At scale. The masses don't smoke and do eat better than they used to, so they live longer, and cost a fortune to treat as they get old. Expensive. Who pays? How? Any good ideas? Tell us.

Related or Semi-related Video

Finance: What is Obamacare?3 Views

00:00

Finance Allah shmoop What is Obama care Well the technical

00:07

term Yeah it's the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act

00:12

Obama care is well just the affectionate nickname like Bubba

00:15

or Sparky or monkey buns Anyway the goal of this

00:18

act was to provide all Americans with health care insurance

00:22

and the intent a noble one Lots of people don't

00:25

have health insurance because they have like literally no money

00:29

or nobody will ensure them because they're oh so sick

00:32

or because well they're just daredevil arrogant thrill seekers who

00:36

never think that gravity will fight them So how did

00:40

our then president expect to be able to get this

00:42

done well enormous financial expense with an extremely high degree

00:47

of difficulty to pull off on a national scale Essentially

00:51

the plan was to meaningfully expand Medicaid which is the

00:55

insurance for the poor and the disabled Well instead of

00:57

covering most people for a relatively modest tax to the

01:00

poor it would offer Medicaid which while still not offered

01:04

to all people was expanded in many states well paid

01:08

for by a variety of taxes including higher taxes for

01:11

individuals in some corporations such as medical device manufacturers and

01:16

taxes on insurance plans It originally forced everyone to either

01:19

buy insurance individually have it provided by an employer or

01:23

else pay a penalty Now if you were a normal

01:26

hardworking healthy ish taxpayer it meant that your tax bill

01:30

instead of being eleven thousand two hundred fourteen dollars would

01:34

now be eleven thousand eight hundred fourteen dollars And a

01:37

lot of Americans were upset at having to take the

01:40

six hundred dollars that they had earmarked toe by Johnny

01:43

clothing and a new swing set next year and now

01:46

give it to the sick and or disabled masses Well

01:49

Obama care essentially change the rules for what is expected

01:52

from a health care insurance plan Doctors are not required

01:55

to treat you but your insurance was required to provide

01:58

a broad basket of benefit like any previous illness you

02:01

had or certain procedures you'd had done had to be

02:04

included in your health plan People had to purchase plans

02:08

that offered this package whether or not they needed the

02:10

full amount of insurance Fair not farewell Let's think about

02:14

this concept because a lot of people were and continue

02:16

to be really angry about Obama care and they're not

02:19

all idiots not like these people On the one hand

02:22

it makes sense that you should get care if you're

02:25

sick right This is in India This is in a

02:27

poor African country where the warlords drive Ferraris as their

02:31

population starves This isn't even an article where the rulers

02:35

barely give a fish to the ruled So the idea

02:38

of covering everyone and anyone who is ill is really

02:40

not a terrible thought The truth is that the added

02:43

cost of covering everyone was managed through subsidies by requiring

02:48

everyone have insurance or pay a fee and requiring broader

02:51

forms of insurance The generally healthy and young subsidized the

02:55

old and sick In addition subsidies for care or offered

02:59

for the indigent Obama care also created incentives for people

03:03

to just pay the penalty and avoid insurance altogether and

03:06

or not really care for themselves or worry about their

03:09

own health management because the government now mandated that coverage

03:13

regardless of an individual's health or lifestyle So let's have

03:16

that fourth Dona Who cares If obese people are ten

03:19

times more likely to get very expensive to treat diabetes

03:22

The government will cover the cost O And how do

03:26

you feel about that at Cole who's always riding his

03:28

motorcycle eighty miles an hour between cars on the freeway

03:31

with no helmet Yeah he crashes Doesn't die He costs

03:35

a million dollars of insurance or government money depending on

03:38

the type of coverage as to live in the hospital

03:40

for you know five months Taxpayers will have to spend

03:44

their money on that guy instead of offering computer science

03:47

courses to their entire district under the federal matching funds

03:51

for education that we're supposed to be there Well the

03:53

truth is our budgets are finite and expanding Medicaid wasn't

03:57

free We are a hugely indebted country with most of

04:01

our states in analogous ly bad financial shape So money

04:04

isn't free And when we pay for things they come

04:06

out of other things And Obama care basically made the

04:10

decision that the motorcycle guy can get coverage at similar

04:13

rates to the rest of us regardless of how much

04:16

risk he takes And yes he's the extreme case and

04:19

a lot of other less extreme and way more positive

04:23

cases were covered as well But if it was your

04:25

kid's computer science courses that were canceled to reallocate tax

04:29

dollars to that motorcycle ball Well you'd give pause right

04:33

Did Obama care really encourage people to care less than

04:35

they already did about their health Probably not But it

04:38

did create a kind of adverse selection in that the

04:41

worst health managers or least healthy people who were likely

04:44

the most expensive to treat would be encouraged to opt

04:48

in to Obama care and just keep on keeping on

04:51

with Joe Camel and the gang and not worry Be

04:54

happy As Obama care was rolled out it expanded coverage

04:57

dramatically so that it wasn't just for cataclysmic things like

05:00

lung cancer and diabetes And under ten broad categories healthcare

05:04

costs were codified and reapportioned So you had emergency services

05:08

like ambulances And then he had drugs covered basically an

05:11

expansion of Part D of Medicare mapped onto Medicaid Add

05:15

to this coverage maternity leave Then it also added in

05:18

the castle for allowing kids to stay on there parentsplans

05:21

until they were age twenty six Then an added premium

05:24

costs for old people that were essentially rent control That

05:28

is those costs Toe old people could not be more

05:31

than three times the cost for the same service to

05:33

young people and remember that market forces would dictate that

05:37

young people on a relative basis almost never get sick

05:40

when compared tto old people So the real market costs

05:43

were away more than three times like the rent control

05:45

was really inefficient And again these extra costs beyond what

05:49

the market would naturally dictate they should be came out

05:53

of the pockets of the hardworking money earning taxpayers through

05:56

Medicaid expansion or subsidies for providing insurance And plus while

06:00

it raised is the cost of insurance for healthy people

06:03

who have always had coverage because they had to subsidize

06:07

the care of the sick And then there was the

06:09

smoker provisioned Yeah remember Obama smoked So uh this lit

06:14

a fire under his opponent's part of Obamacare also capped

06:17

the cost to smokers who used to pay higher rates

06:20

for their insurance It capped cost two smokers such that

06:23

they couldn't be charged more than one point five times

06:26

the normal rates of non smokers even if they were

06:29

ten times more Likely is a group tohave very expensive

06:32

to treat health care problems And this whole program was

06:35

structured as mandatory meaning that Obama care required that every

06:39

single person in the country have health insurance Not a

06:42

terrible idea but it required employers toe pay for it

06:45

if the company was of a certain size or required

06:48

individuals to purchase it If employers didn't pay and individuals

06:53

didn't purchase Yes they originally faced that penalty that big

06:57

or else thing we were talking about like a motorcycle

06:59

guy Yeah he must pay for insurance Well he's too

07:03

stupid to wear a helmet than you Khun Fairly ask

07:06

Why would he be smart enough to at least Carrie

07:08

basic insurance Well the government then has to essentially force

07:11

him to brush his teeth while he still has a

07:13

few left So Obamacare forced you to carry insurance or

07:16

you pay the fine or penalty if you didn't and

07:19

Trump's tax reform package promptly removed that penalty putting the

07:22

burden back on the individual or set another way If

07:25

that person wants to risk life and limb they should

07:27

be able to just not on the taxpayers nickel Well

07:31

the broader goal financially revolved around the notion that if

07:33

you had a large enough pool of money to cover

07:35

the sick then the healthy who need little to no

07:38

maintenance would essentially foot all the bills So who would

07:41

you guess would then not want this coverage and obese

07:44

diabetic old flower shop worker or a healthy young person

07:48

who could run a sub forty five minutes and K

07:50

Yeah the young people just opted out for better or

07:53

worse Wiser stupid They just didn't sign up for Obama

07:56

care And that was where the beginning of a financial

07:59

wakeup call began Governments or simply bad at predicting consumer

08:03

behavior And if all of this wasn't controversial enough given

08:06

that this country's health issues are regional ahs well a

08:09

cz national meaning that a night stay in the car

08:11

cost way more in Manhattan than it does in Tuscaloosa

08:15

Obama care tried to push down to the state level

08:17

is much admin as it could in the process It

08:20

created state exchanges And that's about geographic states not states

08:25

of consciousness and of course with government workers trying to

08:28

build complex websites while the backend technology and the rollout

08:31

completely failed embarrassingly And for some this was actually surprising

08:36

shocking Even Like when you think of America's best and

08:39

brightest technology people you probably don't think of the D

08:43

m V or the T s A Or the technologies

08:46

that either of those places proffer Anyway the policies gave

08:50

states the right to go it alone and try to

08:51

manage their own Obama care policies are basically just give

08:54

back the money to Medicaid and let the federal government

08:57

deal with things the way they had been So that's

08:59

obamacare In a nutshell Lots of nuts And plenty more 00:09:02.92 --> [endTime] to be Sheldon They passed the donut Yeah

Find other enlightening terms in Shmoop Finance Genius Bar(f)