The whole circus business is built on admiration. See the amazing show! Look at the fat lady! Marvel at the elephants! The circus is all about superlatives, or extremes. To get the applause, the compliments, and the excitement, they focus on fantasy. The more outrageous the acts are, the more people applaud. The audience has no idea what goes on behind the scenes and sometimes it seems like they don't want to. Even when characters know how desolate and dark circus life can be, it still exerts a powerful spell on them. And even in the present-day part of the story, being part of the circus makes you admired; that's why people like McGuinty claim to be part of it even when they weren't. That makes Water for Elephants' Jacob a doubly admirable guy: he joined up not once, but twice.
Questions About Admiration
Who is the most admirable character in the book? The least?
How do the circus characters use the audience's admiration to their advantage?
What kinds of bad things do characters do to gain admiration? What admiration in the book is well-deserved?
Is what Rosie does to August admirable? Why or why not?
Chew on This
At a certain point, no amount of pain is worth the potential admiration that comes with it.
The characters' drive for applause shows that admiration is worth having no matter what the cost.