How we cite our quotes: (Chapter.Paragraph)
Quote #1
Agatha smiled. She patted the bed. I knew what that meant, even though she hadn't done it since I was eight or so. I jumped into the center and arranged myself cross-legged. She climbed up and kneeled behind me. She undid my braids. Then she rested one hand on the crown of my head and used the other to drag a brush through my hair. Tingling ran through my body. I closed my eyes. It was going to be all right now. She'd forgiven me. I knew it. (3.23)
It may seem like Georgie is pretty naïve to think that Agatha is going to get over a breach of trust like this so quickly, but then again, these two are sister. Ovaries before brovaries, yo.
Quote #2
"But let me describe my particular state: I saw the two of you kiss. I told Mr. Olmstead. Mr. Olmstead threw over Agatha. Then Agatha ran off. There's a direct correlation between my telling and Agatha's leaving. If my sister is dead, I bear responsibility. If you think I'm going to accept a piecemeal body as evidence of my sister's death, you do not know me at all. Now, I've got money for a horse." (4.52)
To Georgie's credit, she certainly makes the connections in her explanation to Billy and seems to accept a lot of responsibility. We're wondering why Billy doesn't cave a little faster here, especially considering the part he played in all this.
Quote #3
The worst part (and the part I never wanted to admit) was that a moment before I spoke to Mr. Olmstead, I knew I shouldn't say a word. But up until that moment, I possessed absolute certainty of the rightness of my cause. I would have said, with confidence, that my sister was seeing Mr. Olmstead for his library. (Beware of such convictions, for they are fraught with peril.) (10.49)
Well, Georgie, why didn't you make up some excuse about why you came to visit? You could've said you wanted to check out all his taxidermy and books—that would have sounded totally normal.
Quote #4
Anyway, what did it matter what the kiss meant? If I hadn't told Mr. Olmstead, my sister would still be in Placid, her funeral would not have been held, and I would not be out here searching for her. (10.79)
Yep. Here's an interesting thought: If Georgie hadn't told Mr. Olmstead, would Darlene Garrow still have ended up dead? Does Georgie bear any responsibility for Darlene's death? Yikes.
Quote #5
I heard a half-strangled sound and then Billy began to sob.
I fidgeted for a moment. People don't come to me for comfort and consolation. I don't know why. They don't, is all. But it had led me to conclude that I had no talent for it. Right then, though? I was it. Buck up, I said to myself. I went over, sat down next to him, and laid my hand on his shoulder (like I'd seen others do).
"I can't get her back," he said into his knees. (15.34-36)
Billy confuses us, just as he confuses Georgie. Does he love Agatha? Does he love Polly? He doesn't seem to know his own mind most of the time. Sigh. Love is hard sometimes.
Quote #6
But this time it would be the blood of a man, and not a pigeon.
He deserved it—he killed Agatha, I thought.
My index finger wrapped around the trigger.
How can you be so sure? It was Agatha's voice singing in my head as clear as any spring cardinal's. (17.87-90)
Here, Georgie is passing blame for Agatha's death on to the Garrow Gang, even though she doesn't know for sure that they did it. She's also saying they deserve to pay some pretty serious consequences if they did. This issue of whether anyone gets to decide if someone else lives or dies dominates the rest of the book.
Quote #7
"You manipulated me?" I said.
He did not answer.
"Used me? Answer me, Billy. If it's the last thing you do, you tell me."
Billy opened his mouth. "Yes..."
I stood up and looked down at him prone on the ground, so weak—nearly dead, as far as I could tell.
"So, so sorry… why I came here. To make up."
I stared at him for what seemed like a long time. Finally, I said: "You did not show love to my sister. You never cared for me. You talk to your maker about it." And I walked off. (18.49-55)
Georgie lays down some serious blame here. To be fair, Billy really does deserve it for pulling that little trick with the kiss. He could have told Georgie this long ago at home in Placid, so we're not sure we believe he came on this wild goose chase just to make it up to her. Perhaps he's hoping to rescue Agatha and win her favor this way.
Quote #8
I looked into those blue eyes. "I shouldn't have told you."
"No. I should have listened to Agatha when she explained. I was jealous of her relationship with Billy. If I'm honest." (19.47-48)
Mr. Olmstead is such a good guy, the best of the bunch. Unlike everyone else, he's able to admit he was wrong, quite simply.
Quote #9
Awkwardness abounded. You can read my face like a book, and Billy did. "I'm not here to cause grief. I've done enough. I know it." (21.27)
We have to admit, we wanted more out of a Billy/Georgie reunion scene. They spend the whole book together, and then he says "sorry," and they never see each other again. What? We wanted to see them have it out and see Georgie satisfied with the end.
Quote #10
"Heedless girl," said Aunt Cleo.
"She doesn't know the half of it," said Ma.
I stood slack-jawed. Then I rammed my knee hard into the counter. "I hate her. She deceived us," I said. (23.23-25)
Hmm. We get where Georgie is coming from, but we also get where Agatha is coming from. What was your reaction to the news that Agatha is just fine?