Crossing Brooklyn Ferry Spirituality

Though Whitman wasn't directly associated with the movement, he is often lumped in with American Transcendentalists like Ralph Waldo Emerson and Henry David Thoreau. The Transcendentalists believed in a spiritual unity that underlies that natural world. We come to know about the Soul through nature. "Crossing Brooklyn Ferry" shares this view, and Whitman includes human commerce and industry as a part of nature. You can argue about whether his poetry is "religious" or not, but it's certainly spiritual. One of the reasons Whitman avoids specifically religious language is to be as inclusive as possible. He didn't like dividing people up into sects – like, oh, say, North and South, black and white. (Hint, hint: Whitman was writing around the time of the Civil War).

Questions About Spirituality

1. Would you call Whitman a religious poet? If not, then what's the difference between spirituality and religion?
2. Does the poem give people permission to do evil things? What's that about?
3. Do you think Whitman intends to be passive-aggressive toward religion in certain parts of the poem?
4. How would you translate the speaker's "abrupt curious questionings" into real questions?

Chew on This

The speaker does not condone evil actions like lying, cheating, and adultery, but he accepts that they will always exist and thinks people should not feel so guilty about them.