Study Guide

Upon Julia's Clothes Versions of Reality

Advertisement - Guide continues below

Versions of Reality

In "Upon Julia's Clothes," the speaker's descriptions of Julia's outfit get progressively weirder as the poem develops. At first clothes are just that—clothes—but then they liquefy (3), become a "vibration" (5), and finally are able to glitter (6). Silk is no longer silk by the end, or at least not any silk that is immediately recognizable. So the reality of Julia's outfit gets morphed into a surreal representation of the speaker's all too real feelings for our girl.

Questions About Versions of Reality

  1. What's the deal with Julia's clothes? Are they really glittering, flowing, turning to liquid? 
  2. What do you think Julia's really wearing? Something gorgeous? Or is that all in his head?
  3. Is Julia real? Is she a figment of the speaker's imagination? The author's?

Chew on This

There's nothing real or definite about this girl or her outfit. Herrick's poem is all about how we see objects under the influence of emotions and in very strange ways.

The speaker of "Upon Julia's Clothes" is totally self-centered, bordering on solipsistic. Reality for him is all about what and how he sees the world, nothing else.

This is a premium product

Tired of ads?

Join today and never see them again.

Please Wait...