How we cite our quotes: (Paragraph)
Quote #1
He was delighted with Italy. It was a beautiful country, he said. (2)
Violence and bloodshed somewhat unexpectedly lead the comrade to an experience of beauty and pleasure. Hemingway shows us that although young men during this period suffered tremendously in the midst of political conflict, they also had opportunities to travel the world and experience the beauty of foreign lands. Revolution, communism, and the beauty of the Italian countryside are all part of this man's journey into adulthood.
Quote #2
We had a good trip together. It was early September and the country was pleasant. (3)
Of course, on this trip the men talk about communism and world revolution. The juxtaposition of this peaceful countryside with the comrade's violent hopes for the future might seem a little bizarre. What do you think Hemingway is trying to emphasize by setting the conversation about revolution in such a beautiful natural environment?
Quote #3
He was very eager to walk over the pass while the weather held good. He loved the mountains in the autumn. (8)
Again, the story emphasizes the comrade's love of nature. The comrade even passes up visiting other comrades in Milan in order to head immediately into the mountains. Why do you think the narrator keeps coming back to this aspect of the comrade's character? Is it significant that the beauty of nature takes precedence over visiting comrades?