ShmoopTube

Where Monty Python meets your 10th grade teacher.

Search Thousands of Shmoop Videos

U.S. History 1877-Present 11.1: Separate But Equal 47 Views


Share It!


Description:

"Separate but equal" was a prevailing idea in America for a long time. Thankfully, folks eventually came to the conclusion that it was an oxymoron... emphasis on the moron.

Language:
English Language

Transcript

00:03

sometimes a concept makes us do a double-take

00:05

our minds are programmed to think logically us sane folks anyway so when we [man double-takes and numbers whirl through space]

00:11

come across an oxymoron it makes us skip a beat

00:14

jumbo shrimp yeah those babies are still shrimps we're kind of necessitates that [man holding jumbo shrimp]

00:18

they're small well how about a civil war well let's just shake hands politely

00:23

before we shoot okay sounds a little fishy so how about this idea of separate

00:28

but equal well this was the prevailing legal philosophy in the south after

00:33

reconstruction in Plessy v Ferguson the Supreme Court decided that it was a okay [Supreme Court entrance of building]

00:39

for state governments to keep the races segregated so long as whites and blacks

00:43

got equal services what could possibly go wrong [Judge holding a gavel in court]

00:46

well just you know everything the thing about it was that separate was pretty

00:51

inherently unequal since Jim Crow was running the show the services offered to [Jim Crow in a room as a black man uses a sink]

00:56

blacks were of a far lower caliber than those offered to whites.. the white schools

01:00

were better the white restaurants were nicer even the white toilets were

01:04

cleaner if the US was an apple split in two blacks got the piece that was [US apple split in two]

01:09

smaller and filled with worms. The doctrine of segregation got a federal

01:13

blessing by the Supreme Court in the 1892 case Plessy V Ferguson, Homer Plessy

01:19

a black man who lived in Louisiana had an amazing name refused to sit in a [Homer Plessy sat beside a train]

01:24

segregated train car breaking one of Louisiana's Jim Crow laws well the case

01:29

was taken to the highest levels of the land in an attempt to prove that [Court floating on a cloud]

01:32

segregation was a violation of the protections offered to blacks in the

01:36

13th and 14th amendments. Well the court in all its wisdom ruled that segregation

01:40

did not go against the Thirteenth Amendment because it didn't reinstitute

01:45

slavery the guys in black robes also didn't buy the segregation with against [people with bags on their heads wearing black robes]

01:49

the 14th amendment why? because segregation didn't mean that

01:53

both races weren't still equally protected under the law in fact there [police officers walking down a street]

01:59

was no problem with segregation as long as the facilities were quote separate

02:03

but equal' unquote well having the highest court in the land endorsed

02:07

segregation meant the road to equality was well that much steeper fast forward [two men looking at the road to equality]

02:12

60 years and blacks have been living under the thumb of Jim Crow laws for as

02:16

long as they could remember thankfully there was a shift in American society [Black civillians crushed under Jim Crows thumb]

02:19

after the Second World War we had seen how racism turned to genocide in a

02:24

heartbeat was America finally ready to make some changes at home well the good [People giving thumbs up]

02:29

news was that many Americans were up to the challenge it was a new day in

02:33

America following World War two blacks had proved themselves once again as

02:37

brothers in arms to their white counterparts [Blacks fighting in the World War]

02:39

during the war only to come home to the same old story of racism and segregation

02:43

in the south well the path to greater equality would not be easy

02:47

black organizers and their allies faced steep or even violent resistance to [Man looking at a steep path to equality]

02:52

their efforts but the times they were a-changing thank you Bob Dylan for

02:56

singing it it was time to debunk this myth that separate could ever be equal

03:01

and that unicorns were real though what that wasn't as tough of a myth dispel [Unicorn jumping over a rainbow]

Up Next

Why Does the Constitution Still Work for Us?
5721 Views

Ever heard of a "living document"? They eat and breathe just like the rest of us! They even walk around on their own two legs. Okay, fine—maybe t...

Related Videos

The Puritans and the Division of Church and State
1280 Views

If the Puritans had gotten their way, religion would play a much larger role in lawmaking these days. Want to know more? Watch the video for all th...

Shays' Rebellion
6352 Views

What happened between the creation of the Articles of Confederation and the ratification of the current U.S. Constitution? This video analyzes the...

There's More Than One Way to Crack a Modernist Egg
539 Views

The Modernists thought the world had a lot of problems, and they were intent on fixing them—or at least talking about fixing them. Unfortunately,...

Federalism
2532 Views

This video explains Federalism and the quest for a fair balance between state and national power. It covers the progression and compromises of Fede...