How we cite our quotes: (Chapter.Paragraph)
Quote #1
Some of them had loved her for years. They had every recording she had ever made. They kept a notebook and wrote down every place they had seen her, listing the music, the names of the cast, the conductor. There were others there that night who had not heard her name, who would have said, if asked, that opera was a collection of nonsensical cat screechings, that they would much rather pass three hours in a dentist's chair. These were the ones who wept openly now, the ones who had been so mistaken. (1.2)
It's every pop star's dream come true: instantly making everyone at the show a fan. This may sound a little unlikely, but maybe Patchett is trying to tell us that some experiences are so striking they can bowl us over with wonder when we are least expecting it. No surprise that this is at the beginning of the book. It's kind of what the whole novel is about.
Quote #2
He [Mr. Hosokawa] had never sought her [Roxane Coss] out or made himself to be anything more than any other member of the audience. He did not assume his appreciation for her talent exceeded anyone else's. He was more inclined to believe that only a fool would not feel about her exactly how he felt. There was nothing more to want than the privilege to sit and listen. (1.13)
Mr. Hosokawa isn't an artist, but he's someone who responds to the awe and amazement that a great artist produces. Maybe he's a great audience instead. He's not the only one in Bel Canto, though he's a great example of someone any artist would pay to have in the audience (or, well, be happy to accept money from).
Quote #3
No one could see her objectively anyway. Even those who saw her for the first time, before she had opened her mouth to sing, found her radiant, as if her talent could not be contained in her voice and so poured like light through her skin. (2.7)
Maybe people looking for a prom date should ditch the makeup or bowtie and go for singing lessons. The wonder Roxane's voice produces makes her beautiful to everyone, as Mr. Hosokawa's thoughts while he's lying on the floor the first night make perfectly clear.
Quote #4
Too often in these moments of listening he [Father Arguedas] had felt his soul fill with a kind of rapture, a feeling he could not name but was disquieted by—longing? Love? Early in his seminary training he had set his mind to giving up opera as other young men had set their minds to giving up women. He thought there must be a darkness in such passion, especially for a priest. Lacking any real or interesting sins to confess, he offered up the imagined sin of opera one Wednesday afternoon as his greatest sacrifice to Christ. (2.106)
Okay, so most people don't think opera is a sin (unless maybe your parents dragged you to one when you were planning to see the latest Mission Impossible movie). But maybe Father Arguedas fears that passion for opera could rival his deep passion for God. That's how intense his experience of awe is when he listens to opera. Father Arguedas is just one example of the many people in the book who are astonished by art. Luckily, the guy he's confessing to tells him opera is okay for priests after all.
Quote #5
But after Messner brought the box [of sheet music for Roxane] into the house everything changed. The terrorists continued to block the doors and carry guns, but now Roxane Coss was in charge. She started the morning at six o'clock because she woke up when the light came in through her window and when she woke up she wanted to work. (6.3)
An opera star bossing terrorists around? Sounds like a bit of a stretch. But maybe Patchett is telling us that no one is immune to the awe and wonder art can cause. Art is almost like a superpower in Bel Canto—something that changes the game for good.
Quote #6
There had been no girls like Carmen at university. There had never been a girl like Carmen. What a sense of humor one would need to believe that the woman you love is not in Tokyo or Paris or New York or Athens. The woman you love is a girl who dresses as a boy and she lives in a village in a jungle, the name of which you are not allowed to know, not that knowing the name would be particularly helpful in trying to find it. (7.17)
When Gen thinks this, it really means something. Since he's a translator, Gen has seen a lot of the world, and he could easily live in Tokyo, Paris, New York, or Athens. So it's especially intriguing that he falls for Carmen, a woman whose first language he can't even understand. Gen's love, like Roxane's art, seems to involve a wonder that goes beyond the boundaries of language.
Quote #7
"Our family was no different from the other families in our building except for this book. So extraordinary a thing was this book. Masterworks of the Impressionist Period it was called. No one knew we had it. We were never allowed to speak of it because my grandmother was afraid someone would come and try and take it away from her. The paintings were by Pissarro, Bonnard, van Gogh, Monet, Manet, Cézanne, hundreds of paintings. The colors we saw at night while she turned the pages were miraculous. Every painting we were to study. Every one she said was something that deserved great consideration. There were nights that she only turned two pages and I'm sure it was a year before I had seen the book in its entirety." (7.122)
Fyodorov (the guy who gives this speech) must have aced art history. But he learned something even more important from his grandmother's book: how to pay attention to something beautiful and how to surrender to the amazement beauty brings. That's why he's so in love with Roxane's voice, and why he plucks up the courage to tell her about it.
Quote #8
"Every now and then she wouldn't bring out the book at all. She would say she was tired. She would say that so much beauty hurt her. Sometimes a week or even two could pass. No Seurat! I remember feeling almost frantic, such a dependency I had come to feel for those paintings. But it was the rest from it, the waiting, that made us love the book so madly. I could have had one life but instead I had another because of this book my grandmother protected," he said, his voice quieter now. "What a miracle is that? I was taught to love beautiful things. I had a language in which to consider beauty. Later that extended to the opera, to the ballet, to architecture I saw, and even later still I came to realize that what I had seen in the paintings I could see in the fields or a river. I could see it in people. All of that I attribute to this book." (7.122)
Maybe the last Monet you saw didn't change your life. It was probably kinda fuzzy. But for Fyodorov, painting was the way he fell in love with beauty. It's given him the ability to be in awe of beauty wherever he finds it. Bel Canto seems to be telling us that seeing beauty this way is a talent in itself, almost as amazing as making beauty.
Quote #9
He did not compare himself to her. There was no comparison. She was the singer. He was only a boy who loved her by singing. Or was it singing he loved? He could no longer remember. He was too far inside. He closed his eyes and followed his voice. Somewhere far away he heard the piano tailing him, then catching up, then leading him ahead. The end of the aria was very high and he had no idea if he would make it. It was like falling, no, like diving, twisting your body through the air without a single thought as to how it might land. (9.8)
Maybe Olympic diving and Pavarotti don't seem too similar, but Cesar thinks of them as connected. Metaphor alert! Like a fancy dive, opera requires a lot of courage and a lot of twists and turns. And like a diver, a singer has to have a certain recklessness to plunge into the difficult and athletic music of opera. Sounds like that recklessness comes from the amazement Cesar experiences while singing or listening to Roxane.
Quote #10
When he [Mr. Hosokawa] opened the door to her [Roxane's] room there were tears in his eyes more often than not, and he was grateful for the darkness. He didn't want her to think that anything had gone wrong. She came to him and he pressed his damp face into the fall of lemon-scented hair. He was in love, and never had he felt such kindness towards another person. Never had he received such kindness. Maybe the private life wasn't forever. Maybe everyone got it for a little while and then spent the rest of their lives remembering. (10.8)
Could we live all the time with the adrenaline of a rock concert or that teary feeling at the end of The Notebook? Lots of people couldn't. Maybe that's what Mr. Hosokawa means here when he wonders if people only get a private life for a little while. Right now, he has the chance to be carried away by beauty. But will it last when the crisis is over and everyone goes back to the real world? Can awe and amazement define people's everyday experiences, or is it more of a special occasion kind of thing?