How we cite our quotes: (Chapter.Paragraph)
Quote #1
"I'll sing in the dark," Roxane Coss called out, "if someone will get me a candle." (1.20)
Our Shmoop Metaphor Detector is going crazy here. This is one of those lines that tells us something about the whole book. Roxane thinks she's just responding to a temporary power outage here, but as everyone knows by now, the mansion is about to be taken over by terrorists. So what she's saying here is foreshadowing the whole story, which is all about making something beautiful out of a seemingly terrible situation. That's what the characters are doing when they find the courage to dream, hope, and plan in a tough situation.
Quote #2
It was as if a white light filled up the priest's chest, a hot sort of brightness that made his eyes water and his heart beat like a desperate man pounding on the church door at night. Had he been able to lift up his hands to touch her he could not be sure he could have stopped himself. But it didn't matter. He was paralyzed by her voice, the music of speaking, the rhythmic loops of the names that passed through her lips, into the phone, and then into Manuel's ear some two miles away. The priest knew then for sure that he would survive this. That there would come a day when he would sit at Manuel's kitchen table in his small apartment cluttered with music and they would shamelessly recount the pleasure of this exact moment. He would have to live if only to have that cup of coffee with his friend. And while they would remember, try to place in order the names that she spoke, Father Arguedas would know that he had been the more fortunate of the two because it was he whom she had looked at when she spoke. (5.103)
Father Arguedas is an intriguing character because he sees what is unique and in some way wonderful in the world created by the crisis, but he also hopes for something back in the real world. Maybe that's because he has a clear and satisfying role out there. He may not be famous or powerful, but he has real commitments to the people in his church and real friendships with them, as well as a clear role as their priest. That may be why it's easier for him to transition into his post-crisis life than for someone like Mr. Hosokawa, who comes to feel that his pre-hostage role in life was somehow stunted and unsatisfying.
Quote #3
The priest knew he committed the sin of pride and still he was overjoyed at having been able to play a role in bringing in the music. He was still too dizzy from the sound of Roxane's voice to express himself properly. He looked to see if the windows were open. He hoped that Manuel had been able to hear a line, a note, from where he stood on the sidewalk. What a blessing he had received in his captivity. The mysteries of Christ's love had never been closer to him, not when he said the mass or received communion, not even on the day he took holy orders. He realized now he was only just beginning to see the full extent to which it was his destiny to follow, to walk blindly into fates he could never understand. In fate there was reward, in turning over one's heart to God there was a magnificence that lay beyond description. At the moment one is sure that all is lost, look at what is gained! (5.196)
Oh hayyy, Shmoop Metaphor Detector. This section may be explained in religious language, but it's describing more than just Father Arguedas' experience. Most of the characters in the book come to feel that the horrible, sinking feeling they had when they realized they were stuck in a hostage crisis ended up opening up an experience of art and exploration beyond description.
Quote #4
Would it be the worst thing in the world if nothing happened at all, if they all stayed together in this generous house? Carmen prayed hard. She prayed while standing near the priest in hopes it would give her request extra credibility. What she prayed for was nothing. She prayed that God would look on them and see the beauty of their existence and leave them alone. (5.205)
The terrorists as well as the hostages find their hopes and dreams being changed by the new world they've entered into. And rest assured praying for "nothing" means praying for the big, fat something of living in an impossible paradise for all eternity.
Quote #5
For the rest of Gen's life he will remember this night in two completely different ways.
First, he will imagine what he did not do: In this version, he takes Carmen's hand and leads her out the gate at the end of the front walkway. There are military guards on the other side of the wall but they, too, are young and asleep, and together they pass them and simply walk out into the capital city of the host country. Nobody knows to stop them. They are not famous and nobody cares. They go to an airport and find a flight back to Japan and they live there, together, happily and forever. (8.198-200)
Gen is just starting to imagine a completely different future for himself with Carmen as the hostage crisis draws to an end. Here the narrator tells us about the future Gen didn't quite imagine in time. But would it really have worked if he'd thought to leave with Carmen at this moment? It's hard to believe they could really avoid being detained by the authorities, however much they and we might want to believe they could have a life together. Ah, the echoes of Romeo and Juliet…
Quote #6
Then he will imagine exactly what did happen: It did not occur to him to leave, as it does not occur to a dog to leave once he has been trained to stay in the yard. He only feels blessed for the little freedom he is given. Carmen takes his hand and together they walk to the place where Esmeralda held picnics for the Vice President's children, a place where the wall curves back and makes a pocket of grass and slender trees and there is no clear view of the house. Carmen kisses him and he kisses her and from then on he will never be able to separate the smell of her from the smell of night. (8.201-202)
Now Patchett tells us what Gen and Carmen actually got: not a whole future together, but an intense and brief time of being in love. Is their dream one so intense and different from everyday life that it could only last this brief time? Food for thought, Shmoopers.
Quote #7
He wished he could stop time. As much as Mr. Hosokawa was overwhelmed by love, he could never completely shake what he knew to be the truth: that every night they were together could be seen as a miracle for a hundred different reasons, not the least of which was that at some point these days would end, would be ended for them. He tried not to give himself over to fantasies: he would get a divorce; he would follow her from city to city, sitting in the front row of every opera house in the world. Happily, he would have done this, given up everything for her. But he understood that these were extraordinary times, and if their old life was ever restored to them, nothing would be the same. (10.7)
Mr. Hosokawa has started to dream of a completely different future than he could ever have imagined before. Maybe he could be with Roxane Coss for the rest of his life. How dope would that be? But he's also not too sure this would work in the real world. It's a question near the heart of Bel Canto. If something strange and intense like art or crisis opens up a whole new world for you, what happens when the real world comes back? And we're not just talking the next season of MTV's naughtiest show. Kind of the opposite, actually.
Quote #8
He [Messner] sighed. There was no such place as Switzerland. Truly, time had stopped. He had always been here and he would always be here. "I'm afraid those are your two choices," he said. (10.78)
Messner thinks this at a moment when almost everyone else in the story is enjoying life in the house and doesn't want it to change. Others are relishing the sense that time has stopped. But Messner lives half in the real world and half in negotiations in the house, and he realizes that the situation in the house is its own thing, out of the usual experience of time. For him, that's a problem, because he wants to go back to his real life in Switzerland. His hopes and plans are more realistic than most of the others', whether that's good or bad.
Quote #9
It was too much work to remember things you might not have again, and so one by one they opened up their hands and them let go. Except for Messner, whose job it was to remember. And Simon Thibault, who even in his sleep thought of nothing but his wife. (10.94)
In case you hadn't noticed, most of the people in the house forget the hopes, dreams, and plans they had before the crisis. That's what lets them imagine new futures in the house. Thibault has an edge in transitioning back to the reality that's bound to start sneaking back in, and that's because he hasn't forgotten his wife. His love connects him to ordinary life and makes him remember it.
Quote #10
"When I hear Roxane sing I am still able to think well of the world," Gen said. "This is a world in which someone could have written such music, a world in which she can still sing that music with so much compassion. That's proof of something, isn't it? I don't think I would last a day without that now." (Epilogue.28)
What's left after you've entered a dream world and reentered reality? Maybe it's art, the hope and the intensity of experience available through human creativity at its best and most intense. It's out of our control whether we have radically transformative experiences like the one started by the hostage crisis in Bel Canto (and really, it might not be the greatest idea to go looking for that kind of experience). But practically anyone can experience art, and find hope and joy and transformation in that experience. Inspiring, isn't it?