I've Been to the Mountaintop: Main Idea

    I've Been to the Mountaintop: Main Idea

      Onlookers, Go Home. Or, Actually, Don't.

      "Don't be a spectator in the game of life." We're willing to bet you've heard that one before. It means you're missing out on a lot of what life has to offer.

      The fact is that the most important reason not to be a spectator in the game of life is that life isn't a game. It's the real deal. And not participating in life deprives us of wonderful experiences—but it also deprives others of everything we have to offer.

      That's the big idea Dr. King is trying to stuff into his audience's heads in "I've Been to the Mountaintop." What he's saying is basically: these sanitation workers need a helping hand. If everyone waits for someone else to step up, no one will. If everyone minds their own business or sits around watching people suffer, the sufferers will keep on suffering.

      So: who'll do something about it? Any volunteers?

      How about…you?

      Questions

      1. Pick some problems facing our world today and compare them with the Memphis sanitation strike. Do you agree with Dr. King that ordinary people can bring about significant social and political change? Is it still possible in our time? Does this speech offer us any good advice about how to do that, or is it outdated?
      2. Could you answer Dr. King's call to serve others in "I've Been to the Mountaintop"? Would you be willing to risk your job, your good standing at school, your life, even your favorite sweater, to help someone you don't even know?
      3. Just how much help do we owe one another? Is there an acceptable minimum? A maximum? Is Dr. K asking too much of his audience? Too little?
      4. Flight attendants tell us to put on our own oxygen mask before helping others, which…makes sense: a suffocating person is no good to anyone (and we don't want the whole plane looking like Blue Man Group). Can we expand this idea to life in general? Based on this speech, how do you think Dr. King would respond? What would his arguments be? Do you agree?

      Chew On This

      People have a responsibility to themselves and to their families, and Dr. King's efforts to guilt-trip people into sacrificing their own health, jobs, etc. for strangers is ethically dubious.

      As gazillions of social media profiles proclaim, "The only thing necessary for the triumph of evil is that good men do nothing." But life is more complicated than that. MLK's experience with the Invaders exemplifies the fact that the main obstacle to solving societal problems is not lack of participation, but instead the difficulty of coming to a consensus about what should be done.

      Quotes

      Quote #1

      And also, in the human rights revolution, if something isn't done and done in a hurry to bring the colored peoples of the world out of their long years of poverty[,] their long years of hurt and neglect, the whole world is doomed. (12.1)

      Even though it can feel safer just to stay put and maintain the status quo, Dr. K reminds us here that doing nothing can be just as risky as doing something—maybe even more so. Doing something is a choice, but so is doing nothing. No matter what, we can't escape responsibility, so we'd better look it in the face.

      Quote #2

      And we've got to say to the nation, we know how it's coming out. For when people get caught up with that which is right and they are willing to sacrifice for it, there is no stopping point short of victory. (16.3–4)

      Do you think Dr. K is actually saying that enthusiasm and sacrifice make success inevitable, or just that success can't happen without them?

      Here's a really big question for you: The Civil Rights Movement certainly wasn't the first effort by African Americans to overcome oppression. There were slave insurrections and civil rights efforts long before the CRM proper, and the people involved in them definitely didn't lack passion or bravery. So why did it take so long to achieve civil rights?

      Quote #3

      And when we have our march, you need to be there. If it means leaving work, if it means leaving school, be there. Be concerned about your brother. (26.4–6)

      Doing the right thing can be hard, but if everyone assumes someone else will pick up the slack, then no one will. Think about it: if something's hard for you, it's probably hard for everyone else, and they're most likely hoping you'll be the one to take care of it. Psychologists call this the bystander effect. It's a real thing.

      Here Dr. K acknowledges that his audience will have to make serious sacrifices to participate in this march: they could lose their jobs, get beaten up by the police, who knows. But if no one shows up, there won't be any march—and there won't be any progress.

      Quote #4

      We are going on. We need all of you. (19.13–14)

      Dr. K is speaking to an audience of both sanitation workers and community members—that's the "all of you." Why is it so important that everyone take part in the march? The striking workers are a minority within a minority, a disadvantaged group within a disadvantaged group, a small subset of Memphis African Americans. So they can't do it alone. The big question is, how many people need to get involved for change to happen?

      Quote #5

      But then the Good Samaritan came by, and he reversed the question: "If I do not stop to help this man, what will happen to him?" That's the question before you tonight. […] The question is not, "If I stop to help this man in need, what will happen to me?" The question is, "If I do not stop to help the sanitation workers, what will happen to them?" That's the question. (30.1–2, 5–7)

      Self-interest has its perks: it helps us stay safe, healthy, and successful. But Dr. K warns that, when it comes to helping others, self-interest can get in the way. Like the Good Samaritan, MLK knew all too well that helping people can be dangerous. Many people died rights-martyrs as a direct result of the Civil Rights Movement. But if risk-avoidance had beaten out determination, there wouldn't have been a Civil Rights Movement.

      Quote #6

      Let us rise up tonight with a greater readiness. Let us stand with a greater determination. And let us move on in these powerful days, these days of challenge, to make America what it ought to be. We have an opportunity to make America a better nation. (31.1–4)

      You've heard the phrase "land of opportunity," right? Well, when a society holds itself to a high standard like the Declaration of Independence or Bill of Rights, it's bound to fail sometimes. Just ask the Memphis sanitation workers.

      But MLK suggests that failure, along with the freedom to tackle it (19.5–11), is really an opportunity to make things better. So, paradoxically, failing to clear its own high bar is precisely why America is "the land of opportunity."