- Outside the flower shop Madeleine used to visit, Scottie spots a brunette who looks strikingly like Madeleine.
- He follows her to her apartment and knocks on her door. Totally creepy.
- The woman is startled but reluctantly answers Scottie's questions.
- She's not Madeleine, she says; she's Judy Barton, from Salina, Kansas.
- Scottie doesn't believe her, but she shows ID to prove it.
- Scottie impulsively invites Judy to dinner. After declining politely, she finally agrees.
- Reluctantly, Scottie agrees to leave and come back, giving her time to get ready.
- When he leaves the apartment, Judy sits down to compose a letter. We hear her in voiceover as she writes to Scottie to confess.