Big Two-Hearted River (Parts I and II) Theme of Suffering

Nobody knows the troubles Nick’s seen. No, really. We never get to hear about it. We just know that they’re there because Nick seems to be going through a rough period. It’s the little things that make Nick tick in a big way, and we’re left to put together the pieces of why the movement of fish or the darkness of a swamp set him off. But how are we supposed to get into Nick’s head, short of laying him on a couch and asking him about his mother?

Questions About Suffering

  1. How would you characterize Nick’s suffering? Is it internal, external, mental, emotional, etc.?
  2. How does Nick’s suffering manifest itself?
  3. How do we link Nick’s suffering to experiences from his past?
  4. Do the details of why Nick is the way he is matter to the story?

Chew on This

Try on an opinion or two, start a debate, or play the devil’s advocate.

“Big Two-Hearted River” is more a story about interiority (that’s fancy for inner-world) than it is about physical actions.

Nick’s suffering threatens to boil over at any given moment in the story.