© 2016 Shmoop University, Inc. All rights reserved.
A Modest Proposal

A Modest Proposal


by Jonathan Swift

A Modest Proposal Theme of Greed

Swift shows how greed corrupts the upper echelons of society in A Modest Proposal. While the wealthy hoard land like Monopoly money, the poor have no choice but to beg for tidbits in the street. Worse, it's not like those resources are being put to good use. Limitations on land development mean that peasants can't grow food to eat or sell.

Throughout A Modest Proposal, Swift draws an extended metaphor that connects consuming resources to (literally) consuming children. The wealthy have already eaten up the Irish land, so it's no surprise when they turn to the Irish children to feed their appetites.

Questions About Greed

  1. Who is depicted as greedier: the wealthy Irish or the disinterested English? Why?
  2. Why are the wealthy greedy? Is there a motivating force behind their greed?
  3. How does Swift satirize greed?
  4. Does Swift suggest solutions for curbing greed? Or does he believe that greed is a part of human nature that cannot be changed?

Chew on This

Try on an opinion or two, start a debate, or play the devil’s advocate.

Although the narrator in A Modest Proposal expects his readers to be motivated by greed, he is not greedy himself. Rather, he is genuinely interested in restoring Ireland to its former glory.

Swift suggests that greed is a universal human trait. Although the poor are not in a position to be greedy, he believes that they would gladly sacrifice their children to gain money.

People who Shmooped this also Shmooped...