How we cite our quotes: (Chapter.Paragraph)
Quote #1
I was the elder by a few minutes. I always treasured the thought of those minutes. They represented the only time in my life when I was the center of everyone's attention. From the moment Caroline was born, she snatched it all for herself. (2.3)
Louise has been jealous of Caroline since the very beginning. Sure, we can't blame her, but it's not a good way to start out a life.
Quote #2
Ten days after our birth, despite the winter wind and a threat of being iced in, my mother took Caroline on the ferry to the hospital in Crisfield. My father had no money for doctors and hospitals, but my mother was determined. Caroline was so tiny, so fragile, she must be given every chance of life. My mother's father was alive in those days. He may have paid the bill. I've never known. What I do know is that my mother went eight or ten times each day to the hospital to nurse Caroline, believing that the milk of a loving mother would supply a healing power that even doctors could not.
But what of me? "Who took care of me while you were gone?" The story always left the other twin, the stronger twin, washed and dressed and lying in a basket. Clean and cold and motherless.
Again the vague look and smile. "Your father was here and your grandmother. (2.10-12)
Louise has so many hang-ups about her sister that she's even jealous that Caroline almost died as a baby while Louise was left home happy and healthy. Not sure whether you're jealousy is out of control? Envying someone else's near-death experience is a good sign it is.
Quote #3
There was something about the thought of God being with me that made me feel more alone than ever. It was like being with Caroline.
She was so sure, so present, so easy, so light and gold, while I was all grey and shadow. I was not ugly or monstrous. That might have been better. Monsters always command attention, if only for their freakishness. My parents would have wrung their hands and tried to make it up to me, as parents will with a handicapped or especially ugly child. Even Call, his nose too large for his small face, had a certain satisfactory ugliness. And his mother and grandmother did their share of worrying about him. But I had never caused my parents "a minute's worry." Didn't they know that worry proves you care? Didn't they realize that I needed their worry to assure myself that I was worth something? (3.57-58)
Yes, Caroline is the perfect one and Louise is just, well, there. Louise is grasping at anything to get some attention. Maybe she could have been ugly? Maybe someone could have worried about her once or twice? This is jealousy at its worst.
Quote #4
I would search the Scriptures, but not for enlightenment or instruction. I was looking for some tiny shred of evidence that I was not to be eternally damned for hating my sister. Repent and be saved! But as fast as I would repent, resolving never again to hate, some demon would slip into my soul, tug at the corner, and whisper, "See the look on your mother's face as she listens to Caroline practice? Has she ever looked at you that way?" And I would know she hadn't. (6.12)
Yup, Louise just cannot let it go. She knows that hating Caroline can't be right, but she just can't help it—call it what you like, but something in Louise just won't let her get rid of the jealousy.
Quote #5
Just before noon Call came by and asked if Caroline or I was going down to the Captain's.
"Sure," said Caroline cheerfully. "Soon as we finish carrying the canning upstairs." High water had more than once washed through our downstairs, and my mother didn't want to take a chance on having the fruits and vegetables she had bought on the mainland and put up for the winter dashed to the floor or swept away. "You coming, Wheeze?"
Who did she think she was, inviting me to go see the Captain? As if she owned both him and Call. Call, who had always belonged to me because nobody else besides his mother and grandmother would have him, and the Captain, who finally through all our troubles and misunderstandings had become mine as well. Now, because of one afternoon of giving away a batch of drugged cats, she thought she could snatch them both for herself. I muttered something angry but unintelligible. (10.4-6)
This is classic Caroline—taking something that belongs to Louise. This time, it's Louise's only friends. If Louise had been more secure in herself and her friendships, she might not have minded Caroline tagging along, but instead, jealousy rears its ugly head yet again.
Quote #6
"The three of us are going to see the Captain."
"Please stop it, Caroline. It's none of your business. You hardly even know him." I was trying to force my voice to remain calm with the result that all the unreleased shrieks were clogging my throat.
"I do know him, Wheeze. And I care about what happens to him."
"Why? Why do you always try to take over everybody else's life?" I thought I might strangle on the words.
She gave me her look which indicated that once again I had lost all sense of proportion. "Oh, Wheeze," was all she said. (13.38-42)
Wow, Caroline sure is patronizing. We totally get why Louise can't stand her sometimes. Louise is having a serious crisis here—Caroline has just suggested that the Captain get married. What? Can't Caroline see how that affects other people? How jealous Louise must be? Nope—she just brushes her sister off and goes about her business.
Quote #7
Of course I was jealous of Call, but I was surprised to realize how very much I missed him. All my life my father had followed the water, so it had never seemed strange to have him gone, but Call had always been around, either with me or close by. Now we only saw him at church.
Caroline made a fuss over him every Sunday. "My, Call, we sure do miss you." How could she know? Besides, it didn't seem quite ladylike to say something like that, straight out […]
You could sense his pride that he had come at last into a man's estate, the sole support of the women upon whom he had until now depended. I knew we had been growing apart since summer, but I had been able to blame that on Caroline. Now it was more painful, for the very things that made him stronger and more attractive were taking him deep into the world of men—a place I could never hope to enter. (14.50-52)
This is sad. Louise's best friend—her only friend, really—has moved beyond her. He's a man and he has work to do, and she's not able to follow, no matter how badly she wants to. Not only is Louise jealous of Call here, she's annoyed with Caroline. Her twin sister can say exactly what she's thinking and no one seems to mind. It's Louise that misses Call, but she just can't get the words out the right way. Poor Louise.
Quote #8
"You know how much I think of you, how indebted both Trudy and I are—were—to all of you. And now—" He could hardly contain himself. He smiled at me. "I have Sara Louise to thank for the idea. You see, Trudy left a little legacy. I didn't know what to do with it, because I swore to myself I would never touch her money. There isn't a great deal, but there is enough for a good boarding school." He was beaming all over. "I've investigated. There will be enough for Caroline to go to Baltimore and continue her music. Nothing would make Trudy happier than that, I know."
I sat there as stunned as though he had thrown a rock in my face. Caroline!
Caroline jumped up and ran over and threw her arms around his neck.
"Caroline, wait," my mother was saying. Surely she would point out that she had two daughters. "Captain, this is very generous, but I can't—I'd have to talk with my husband. I couldn't—"
"We must convince him, Miss Susan. Sara Louise, tell her how you were saying to me just the other day that someone should understand that special circumstances demand special solutions—that Caroline ought to be sent to a really good school where she could continue her music. Isn't that right, Sara Louise?"
I made a funny sound in my throat that must have resembled a "yes." The Captain took it for approval. (14.78-83)
Yet another horrible moment in Louise's life; yet another thing Caroline gets that Louise will never have access to. Nope, we don't blame her one bit for feeling jealous.
Quote #9
At bedtime Caroline finally remembered that she had a sister. "Please don't mind too much, Wheeze. It means so much to me."
I just shook my head, not trusting myself to reply. Why should it matter if I minded? How would that change anything? The Captain, who I'd always believed was different, had, like everyone else, chosen her over me. Since the day we were born, twins like Jacob and Esau, the younger had ruled the older. Did anyone ever say Esau and Jacob? (15.6-7)
This is pretty true: Louise's feelings on the subject don't really matter. What is Louise supposed to do? Make a scene and stop Caroline from going? No one would ever let Louise's jealousy get in the way of beautiful and perfect Caroline's future.
Quote #10
Call was not discharged as soon as he had hoped, so it was the next year, the day before Christmas 1946, that he and Caroline were married. My parents went up for the ceremony in the Juilliard chapel, which, I gathered, was stark in word and dress, but rich in Bach and Mozart, thanks to Caroline's school friends.
I stayed home with Grandma. It was my choice […] Perhaps my soul, now as calloused as my hands, could have borne such a wedding. I don't know. I was glad not to be put to the test. (17.1-2)
We're glad for you, too, Louise. Can you imagine watching your hated twin sister marry the man you loved—or, at least, might have loved? It'd be pretty rough.