The River Between Us Warfare Quotes

How we cite our quotes: (Chapter.Paragraph)

Quote #1

They'd divvied up, some for the North, more for the South. Why didn't they just fight it out right here in the road, fair and square? Did they even know it could end with them killing one another in some godforsaken loblolly far from home? (2.42)

Tilly has a point. Fighting it out on a small scale right there at home would save all of these guys the hassles of training camps—you know, like measles and dysentery.

Quote #2

The minute Mama heard that the cotton states were seceding, she feared anew for Noah.

Then this month when Little Napoleon Beauregard fired on Fort Sumter in Charleston Bay, the whole sky darkened. Another week and Lincoln had proclaimed his blockade of the Southern ports. Now he was calling for seventy-five thousand volunteers to fight. (3.8-9)

Nice. Tilly gives us a quick peek at the way the war's shaping up (hint—it's North versus South), so we don't have to do the old web search to figure out what's going on.

Quote #3

And the boats still came. We didn't know how quiet the first weeks of war can be. We had no experience of war. (6.2)

Even after a war is declared, it can take a while for it to trickle down from governments to everyday life, so we can't blame Tilly for thinking things (including steamboats) are going to drift along in the same way for a while.

Quote #4

They issued them no weapons up at Camp Dunlap, and no uniforms either. Noah wrote to say the legs of his butternut jeans were growing beards. They were given rations of salt pork and dry beans to cook for themselves if they could, or eat raw. That and thirteen dollars a month was their pay.

It was an army that didn't know how to be an army, and it treated its soldiers like beasts of the field. (9.4-5)

By 1861, the United States had been a legit country for four score and, uh, five years, according to Lincoln's math, and had fought a whole handful of wars. So, you'd think we'd have had our act together about how to train troops by that point, but no.

Quote #5

But everybody said that our war, the war on the river, would be waged from Cairo. In our ignorance we still couldn't believe they'd send boys unprepared into battle, though I suppose Cass knew better, in the way she knew things. (9.8)

Unprepared troops have been sent into battle since there have been battles, but in every war, it comes as a big shock. "The war on the river" refers to the Mississippi theater of the war, which somehow never gets as much name recognition as Gettysburg and other eastern battles.

Quote #6

People swarmed wherever you looked. Men mainly, of every age. Most were in uniform or parts of uniform. Some went about their business, but more of them were drunk—reeling drunk and fighting drunk and sleeping it off with their boots in the ditches and their heads cradled in filth.

"They train on the parade grounds all morning," the doctor said, "but nobody can decide what to do with them the rest of the day. The able-bodied." (10.26-27)

Sounds like somebody better figure out what to do with them before they end up with an army that marches on its stomach (you know, because they're all so drunk they're crawling) but dies from liver failure.

Quote #7

"Military justice is rough justice," Dr. Hutchings said, "or no justice at all." But he went on to say he'd end up in uniform, doctoring for the army. He had thought he'd do more good as a "contract surgeon," a civilian doctor, but he was finding out different. (10.42)

Poor Dr. Hutchings. He doesn't have to go into battle as a doctor, but his job is no picnic, either.

Quote #8

He stands between us in his forage cap, proud in his big new uniform that he seems to be peering out of, not wearing. But his arms hang stiff at his sides, the cuffs to his knuckles, a soldier boy before the battle. There's something missing in his eyes, a vacancy, as if he couldn't wait and has gone on ahead. (13.4)

Now this image of Noah just gives us the shivers. He's gone all visionary on us, just like Cass and Calinda. Does he see the loss of his arm up ahead?

Quote #9

We pushed forward in the mob when the first gangplank came down. The able-bodied carried the wounded on litters. Now we saw sights we'd been spared in the hospital tent. Blood soaked through the stretchers from the stumps of legs until the gangplank ran with it. We heard the cries of the torn and saw a boy who'd been shot full in the face. But it wasn't Noah because this boy's matted hair was black.

No one had witnessed the fruits of war till now. Men in the crowd wept like children. Women shrieked and keened and fell on their knees. But we didn't. We might miss Noah. (13.19-20)

Sounds awful. It's so strange to think of people literally waiting a few miles upriver for the results of a battle. Think of it: a loved one could go a short distance away to fight and might come back fine, wounded, or dead.

Quote #10

"You'll think I'm too old for a soldier," he said, "and maybe I am. But they'll need doctors. I didn't want to spring it on you at the last minute. You'd have to take over at home till I got back, be there for your mother and the boys."

In the quiet, I heard my dad waiting. He wanted it to be all right with me. He wanted my approval. Nothing this grown-up had happened to me before. This was something Grandma Tilly couldn't understand—how war promises a boy it can make a man out of him. (15.47-48)

Yep, sounds like Howard was on Noah's side all along in this "going off to war" business. Howard and his dad face another war in another century. Does the juxtaposition of these wars make us think about how similar they are, or how different they are? Or both?