How we cite our quotes: (Chapter.Paragraph)
Quote #1
I think the Selection was meant to draw us together and remind everyone that Illéa itself was born out of next to nothing. (1.41)
That's one interpretation of the situation. Another is that the Illéan government uses the Selection as a way to keep the masses placated under the assumption that they too someday might become royalty. It sounds a little conspiratorial, we know, but is it wrong?
Quote #2
"This isn't exactly a rule, but it would be unwise of you to ignore it. When you are invited to do something with Prince Maxon, you do not refuse. No matter what it is." (6.62)
We don't think we have to spell out the subtext of this statement, but needless to say, it's quite troubling. It's bad enough that Illéa is a totalitarian state, but now America literally has to submit her body to the royal family's power. Knowing America, however, she's not likely to give up her freedom so easily.
Quote #3
I was infuriated. [...] I wasn't above the rules; that was what he'd said. But apparently the prince was. And I felt dirty, lower than an Eight. (6.67)
Although you might have expected America to willingly submit to the Illéan government's authority, she refuses to be pushed around by anyone. That's an admirable quality. But how long will it last once she's inside the palace walls?
Quote #4
Something in his voice struck me. There wasn't a trace of sarcasm. This thing that seemed like little more than game show to me was his only chance for happiness. (10.109)
America rightly sees the Selection as an overly elaborate, painfully vapid show of power, but Maxon takes it deadly seriously. This actually makes America like him more. Instead of being the vain, detached ruler that she expected him to be, Maxon is a sincere guy who has no desire to exploit his status for his own advantage.
Quote #5
"America, what did you think I wanted?" He sounded upset. More than upset. Offended. He had obviously guessed what I'd assumed, and he didn't like that one bit. (12.106)
We get that Maxon's feeling are hurt, but he's naive if he doesn't understand the nature of the Selection. He has all of the power in the situation; the girls have none. Now, we're not advocating throwing knees into crotches all willy-nilly, but it's hard to blame America given the circumstances.
Quote #6
I realized that if Maxon had simply been Maxon Schreave and not Maxon, future king of Illéa, he would be the kind of person I would have wanted to be my next-door neighbor. (13.119)
As America gets closer to Maxon, her assumptions about him keep on being proven false. He's not the spoiled brat she assumed him to be; he's really quite sensitive. He's not stiff and arrogant; he's just a tad shy. In this way, we see how Maxon is potentially limited by others' expectations of him, given his high status.
Quote #7
It made me wonder just how many attacks the palace suffered through that we never heard about. Was it far less safe here than I'd thought? (14.2)
One of the ways that the Illéan government retains its power over the people is by controlling the information they receive. After all, the country's biggest news show is shot on location in the palace. That doesn't seem too fair and balanced to us.
Quote #8
I began to wonder just how much we knew about the rebels. Maybe I just didn't understand, but I didn't think they could be blamed for everything that was wrong with Illéa. (14.80)
The more we hear about the rebels, the more we doubt the Illéan government's official narrative regarding the conflict. It just doesn't add up. In fact, now that we're doing the math, it seems like the government conveniently uses the rebels as bogeymen to scare its people. That's a classic technique from the totalitarian playbook.
Quote #9
"So a new nation was formed under Gregory Illéa's name and leadership. [...] He was just a private citizen who donated his money and knowledge. And he changed everything." (17.20)
We gain some insight into the formation of Illéa during the girls' history lesson, and it's an interesting story to say the least. How could some random dude just start a country? Why would he do that? And why did he create this infernal caste system? Unfortunately, this is one mystery that doesn't get revealed in The Selection—guess we'll have to wait for the sequel on that one.
Quote #10
His voice was full of a ringing authority that I had only really heard once—the night he let me into the garden. He was much more attractive when he was using his status for a purpose. (18.8)
This is an important moment for America because it shows that Maxon does care about the struggles of his people and sincerely wants to use his power for good. But it's even bigger for Maxon. For him, this represents the first time that he takes full advantage of his status to do something that's important to him—and important to his country. It's a big step.