Measure for Measure Theme of Justice and Judgment
When a corrupt deputy sentences a man to death for the crime of fornication, Shakespeare asks us to consider whether or not morality can or should be legislated. On the one hand, the play warns that men and women don't necessarily have the right to pass judgment on their fellow human beings. At the same time, Measure for Measure suggests that a person who commits a crime (or sins), should be made to pay – either by making some sort of restitution or by suffering an amount that's commensurate with the suffering he or she has caused.
Questions About Justice and Judgment
- Explain why Claudio has been sentenced to death. Is the sentence just?
- Discuss why the Duke allows Angelo to implement Vienna's laws.
- How does the title, Measure for Measure, speak to the theme of "Justice and Judgment" in the play? Also, describe the relationship between religion and law.
- Does the play think morality can or should be regulated by the government? Do you think it should be?
Chew on This
In the end, Measure for Measure promotes mercy and temperance rather than an "eye for an eye" system of justice.
Although Measure for Measure acknowledges that social problems related to the sex industry exist, it also argues that sex (and morality in general) cannot and should not be regulated by the government.