Anna and Caleb are completely thrilled that they might be getting a new mother in Sarah, Plain and Tall, but their anticipation also means that they're terrified things might not work out. When Sarah comes to stay with them for a trial run, their anxiety level skyrockets as they read into every little sign and thing that she says—hoping to get some hint as to what her decision will be. Caleb, who's younger and more emotional, has an especially hard time keeping his fears and worries in check. It's scary to imagine that the woman he's come to love as a mother might waltz out of their lives.
Questions About Fear
- Why is Caleb so scared that Sarah will leave? What does he stand to lose? What does he stand to gain by her staying?
- Is Jacob afraid that Sarah will leave and never come back? Why or why not? How can you tell?
- How does the family react when the big squall hits their farm?
Chew on This
Even though Anna and Caleb are excited by Sarah's arrival and come to adore her, they're still always terrified she'll decide to leave them.
Sarah isn't afraid of learning new things, fixing roofs, or running out into storms because she's already done the scariest thing ever: leaving behind her family and hometown to come live with a man she's only written to.