We Were Liars Chapter 51 Summary

  • It's Cadence's third week on Beechwood, and a headache takes her out for another two days.
  • The pills in the bottle are running out, and she wonders if Penny or the twins have been dipping into them, or if she's just taking more than she realizes.
  • When she feels better, she goes to Cuddledown, where the Liars are playing Scrabble again.
  • She asks what they did while she was in bed, and they say they celebrated the Fourth of July and went to Downyflake in Nantucket for doughnuts.
  • She asks what kind of doughnuts they got, and they say glazed… but she knows Downyflake only sells cake doughnuts.
  • She wonders why they're lying.