Will Grayson
- At school, Will runs into Tiny, but he's still busy with the play and the other will grayson and all that good stuff.
- At lunchtime, Will makes his way over to the auditorium and overhears Tiny giving Gary advice about playing Phil Wrayson. Tiny explains that Phil says he doesn't care about anything, but he actually totally does, so Gary has to make the audience feel Phil's annoyingness.
- Will half expects Tiny to apologize, but he doesn't because he's much too wrapped up in the play to care. Will surprises himself when he starts crying. He just misses his best friend.
- So he walks out of school and to this Little League field that's on his way home.
- Will just sits there on the bleachers by himself and thinks about the time that he and Tiny played Little League together in sixth grade. When the coach yelled at Will, Tiny hauled off and punched him.
- Will realizes that it's not him who's been stuck with Tiny all these years, it's Tiny who's been stuck with him. Bummer.
- On the way home, Will calls Jane, but she doesn't answer. And he still likes her. A lot.
- At home, Will's dad is there and he knows Will is bummed about something, so he tells him a story. A doctor friend of his has no kids but a super fancy yacht. Well, Will is his yacht—all that time and effort he would have put into a boat has gone into his kid. And Will's dad is just so proud of him.
- That night, Will and his dad are making dinner when Jane stops by. She just has one question for Will: What's her locker combination?
- When Will tells her the right number, Jane says she knew it was him all along. Also, she broke up with the terrible ex-boyfriend at the botanical gardens. It's time to open the box and see if this cat is dead or alive.
- And they kiss. The cat is definitely alive.
- Will invites Jane in for dinner and his dad wonders if Jane was the thing that was really bumming Will out.
- Well, only partly—there's still Tiny—but Will guesses that he can't have everything.